AP Calculus AB and BC
Optimization Classroom Activity: The Open-Top Box
Each group cuts equal squares from the corners of a sheet of letter paper and folds an open-top box. Class data show the volume rising and then falling as the cut grows. Calculus then gives the best cut: about 1.585 inches, for a volume of about 66.15 cubic inches. A full answer key is included.
Objective and materials
Students build a family of boxes from identical sheets, collect the volumes as class data, write the volume as a function of one variable with a domain, and find its absolute maximum with the derivative. The activity serves CED Topic 5.10, Introduction to Optimization Problems, and Topic 5.11, Solving Optimization Problems.
- One sheet of letter paper (8.5 inches by 11 inches) per group, plus spares
- Rulers marked in inches, scissors and tape
- Calculators
- A whiteboard grid for class data: cut size across, volume up
- Optional: dry rice and a measuring cup to compare capacities directly
Seven groups cover the cut sizes in the table below. With fewer groups, drop and then . Students need the product of three lengths for volume, the power rule, and the quadratic formula. The exit check key uses the product and chain rules. Students without them can expand first.
A 45-minute sequence
| Minutes | Teacher move | Student evidence |
|---|---|---|
| 0 to 5 | Hold up a sheet and two sample boxes, one shallow and one deep. Ask which cut size gives the largest volume and collect a written guess from each student. | A guessed cut size in inches. |
| 5 to 17 | Assign each group one cut size. Groups cut, fold, tape, measure and compute. | A taped box with its three measured dimensions and volume. |
| 17 to 24 | Plot each group's point on the board. Ask where the maximum appears to be and how precisely the data locate it. | A class scatter plot and an estimate of the best cut. |
| 24 to 38 | Build and its domain as a class, then have students differentiate and solve. | The volume function, its derivative, the critical point and a justification. |
| 38 to 45 | Compare the calculus answer with the plot. Exit check. | A written exit check. |
Student steps
- Measure and mark a square of side in each corner of the sheet, where is your group's assigned cut size.
- Cut out the four squares. Fold the four flaps up along the lines joining the cuts and tape the corners.
- Measure the inside length, width and height of the box to the nearest sixteenth of an inch.
- Compute the volume as length times width times height and report it to the board.
- Check your measurements against the formulas: length , width , height .
Expected class data
| Cut (in) | Length (in) | Width (in) | Volume (cubic in) |
|---|---|---|---|
Measured volumes will differ slightly from these because of cutting and folding error. The data place the maximum somewhere between and . They cannot say whether the best cut is , or inches. That gap is the reason for the calculus.
The calculus solution
The volume is height times width times length. Every dimension must be positive, and the width reaches zero first, so the domain is .
Differentiate and set the derivative equal to zero.
Since , the solutions are and . The second lies outside the domain, so is the only critical point in the interval.
Justify the maximum. The second derivative is , and , which is negative, so has a local maximum there. It is the only critical point on , and approaches at both ends of the interval while is positive inside, so this local maximum is the absolute maximum.
The best box is about inches long, inches wide and inches tall. A cut of inches is a little more than inches, so a student can build it and set it beside the class boxes.
What students should notice
- The cuts and give the same volume, cubic inches, from very different shapes. A horizontal line can meet the graph of twice, which is what a maximum between them looks like.
- The group with gets cubic inches, within of the true maximum. Near a maximum the graph is nearly flat, so a small error in the cut costs very little volume.
- The derivative gave two candidates and the domain removed one. The domain is part of the solution.
- The best cut is neither the midpoint of the domain nor a round number.
Discussion questions
- Why does the volume fall when the cut gets large, even though the box gets taller? Answer: each extra inch of height removes two inches from both the length and the width. Once the cut passes about inches, the loss in base area outweighs the gain in height.
- What would the box look like at and at ? Answer: at it is a flat sheet with no height. At the width is zero. Both have zero volume, which is why the maximum must occur strictly between them.
- A classmate says the maximum is at because that group had the largest box. How would you respond? Answer: the table only tests seven cut sizes. , which is positive, so the volume is still increasing at and the maximum lies to the right of it.
- Would the best cut change if the box needed a lid? Answer: it depends on where the lid comes from. A lid cut from a second sheet leaves the volume function and the best cut unchanged. A lid cut from the same sheet changes the layout, so the volume function and its critical point change. The method stays the same.
Exit check
A square sheet with side inches is made into an open-top box the same way. Find the cut size that gives the greatest volume, and that volume.
Key: on . By the product rule, . The factor is zero only at the endpoint , so the critical point is inches. changes from positive to negative there, so it is the maximum, and cubic inches.
A4 paper version
For A4 paper, cm by cm, assign whole-centimeter cuts. The volume function is on .
| Cut (cm) | Length (cm) | Width (cm) | Volume (cubic cm) |
|---|---|---|---|
Setting gives , so or . Only cm is in the domain, and the maximum volume is about cubic centimeters.
Extension and follow-up
- General square sheet: for side , and , so the best cut is and the maximum volume is . Ask students to verify the exit check with this formula.
- Capacity check: fill the best box and one neighbor with dry rice and pour each into a measuring cup. One cubic inch is about 16.4 mL, so 66 cubic inches is a little over one liter. Paper walls bulge, so treat this as a rough comparison.
- Ask students to state the objective and the constraint in words before writing any formula, then check their wording with the Optimization Setup Builder.
The optimization problems guide has more worked problems of this kind, and the first derivative test guide covers the justification step.
Worked examples
Worked example
Best cut for a letter-size sheet
Equal squares of side inches are cut from the corners of an by inch sheet, and the sides are folded up to form an open-top box. Find the value of that maximizes the volume.
- Write the volume: , with domain .
- Differentiate: .
- Solve with the quadratic formula: , so or . Only is in the domain.
- Justify: is negative at , so this is a local maximum. It is the only critical point in the domain and approaches at both ends, so it is the absolute maximum.
- Evaluate: .
Cut squares of side about inches. The maximum volume is about cubic inches.
Worked example
Checking a group's claim with the derivative
A group built the box with and measured cubic inches. Use to decide whether a slightly larger cut would have increased or decreased the volume.
- Use .
- Evaluate: .
- Interpret: the derivative is negative, so is decreasing at .
cubic inches per inch of cut. A slightly larger cut would decrease the volume, so the best cut is smaller than inches.
Frequently asked questions
How long does the open-top box activity take?
About 45 minutes: 5 for the opening guess, 12 for building, 7 for the class plot, 14 for the calculus, and 7 for comparison and the exit check.
Can I run it with A4 paper?
Yes. Use whole-centimeter cuts and the A4 table above. The best cut is about 4.04 cm, for a volume of about 1128.5 cubic centimeters.
Do students need the second derivative test?
No. The first derivative test works as well: is positive and is negative, so changes from positive to negative at the critical point between them.
What is the most common student error?
Subtracting from each side length when the fold removes , one square from each end. Having the box in hand lets students see both removed squares along each edge.