AP Calculus AB and BC
Related Rates Classroom Activity: The Sliding Ladder Lab
Lean a meter stick against a wall, slide its foot out 10 cm at a time, and record the height of the top. The foot moves at a steady rate but the top falls faster and faster. Differentiating x squared plus y squared = 100 squared predicts the rate of the top at each position, and the full answer key is included.
Objective and materials
Students measure two linked quantities on a physical ladder model, see that a constant rate in one produces a changing rate in the other, and then derive that changing rate by implicit differentiation with respect to time. The lab serves CED Topic 4.4, Introduction to Related Rates, and Topic 4.5, Solving Related Rates Problems.
- One meter stick per group to act as the ladder (exactly 100 cm long)
- A second meter stick or a tape measure fixed vertically to the wall with tape, zero at the floor
- Masking tape and a marker for floor marks
- A flat wall that meets a hard floor at a right angle
- One recording sheet per student and a calculator
Groups of three work well: one student moves the foot of the stick, one holds the top against the wall and reads its height, one records. Students need the Pythagorean theorem and implicit differentiation. They do not need to have solved a related rates problem before.
Setup, 5 minutes
- Run a strip of masking tape along the floor, perpendicular to the wall. Mark it every 10 cm from the wall, from 10 cm out to 90 cm.
- Tape the measuring stick vertically on the wall above the floor strip, with its zero end on the floor.
- Name the variables on the board: is the distance from the wall to the foot of the ladder, is the height of the top, both in centimeters.
- Set the pretend clock: the foot moves out 10 cm every second, so cm per second throughout.
Measure to the same edge every time
A meter stick has thickness. Read and where the same face of the stick touches the floor and the wall, and keep that choice for all nine positions. Allow for differences of a few millimeters between the measured heights and the table below.
A 40-minute sequence
| Minutes | Teacher move | Student evidence |
|---|---|---|
| 0 to 5 | Set up the wall and floor marks. Ask for a written prediction: if the foot moves at a steady rate, does the top fall at a steady rate? | A one-sentence prediction on the recording sheet. |
| 5 to 15 | Groups place the foot at , then , up to , and record the height of the top each time. | Nine measured heights and eight drops between positions. |
| 15 to 20 | Collect one group's drops on the board. Ask what the data say about the prediction. | A statement that equal moves of the foot give unequal drops of the top. |
| 20 to 32 | Derive as a class from , then have groups fill in the predicted rates. | The differentiated equation and a completed prediction column. |
| 32 to 40 | Discussion questions and the exit check. | Written answers to the exit check. |
Student steps
- Place the foot of the ladder on the 10 cm mark with the top resting against the wall. Read the height of the top to the nearest millimeter and record it.
- Move the foot to the 20 cm mark. This is one second on the pretend clock. Record the new height and the drop since the last position.
- Repeat for every mark through .
- Divide each drop by 1 second to get the average rate of change of over that second, in centimeters per second. Give it a negative sign, because the height is decreasing.
- Check each measured height against .
- After the class derivation, compute the predicted instantaneous rate at each position and compare it with the average rates on either side of it.
The calculus prediction
The ladder, the wall and the floor form a right triangle whose hypotenuse stays 100 cm long. Write the relation first, with both legs as variables.
Differentiate both sides with respect to time . Both and depend on , so each term needs the chain rule. The right side is a constant.
With , the prediction is centimeters per second. Substitute the position only after differentiating. A student who replaces with before differentiating turns a variable into a constant, and its rate of change disappears from the equation.
Answer key: expected measurements and rates
| (cm) | Height (cm) | Drop since last position (cm) | Predicted (cm per second) |
|---|---|---|---|
Each drop took one second, so the drop column is also the size of the average rate over that second. From to the top falls cm, an average rate of cm per second. The instantaneous rates at the two ends of that second are and , and the average sits between them. The same holds for every row.
For a closer comparison at one instant, use the positions on both sides of it. From to the height changes from to in two seconds, an average rate of cm per second. The predicted instantaneous rate at , the middle of that interval, is .
What students should notice
- The foot moves the same 10 cm every second, but the top drops about 1.5 cm in the first recorded second and about 16.4 cm in the last.
- The size of the rate, , grows because increases while decreases.
- The rate of the top depends on the current position. A related rates answer is a rate at one instant, and a different instant gives a different answer.
- The rate is negative because is decreasing. The sign carries meaning and belongs in the answer.
Discussion questions
- At what position is the top falling exactly as fast as the foot is moving? Answer: when , so . Then and cm. The table agrees: the rate passes between and .
- What does the formula predict as the top approaches the floor? Answer: as approaches with near , the ratio grows without bound. At the height is cm and the predicted rate is about cm per second.
- If the foot moved 5 cm each second, how would the rate column change? Answer: every entry would be halved, because is times . The heights would not change.
- Why did we write with letters for both legs but a number for the ladder? Answer: the legs change with time and the ladder length does not. Only quantities that stay fixed for the whole motion may be entered as numbers before differentiating.
Exit check
A 100 cm ladder slides so that its foot moves away from the wall at 4 cm per second. Find the rate of change of the height of the top when the foot is 80 cm from the wall, with units.
Key: at , . Then cm per second. The height is decreasing at about cm per second.
Extension: water in a paper cone cup
A cone-shaped paper cup gives a second lab with the same structure. Stand the cup in a mug, add water 10 mL at a time with a medicine syringe or measuring spoon, and measure the depth after each addition with a marked skewer held along the center line. Equal volumes raise the level less and less as the cup widens.
Measure the cup's top radius and its depth . Similar triangles give the water surface radius at depth , so the volume in cubic centimeters (which equal milliliters) is
The table gives expected depths for a cup with cm and cm, which holds about mL. Recompute it for the cup you have, using .
| Water added (mL) | Depth (cm) |
|---|---|
Students can compare both models with the Related Rates Visualizer, which shows a sliding ladder and a cone tank, and practice the setup steps with the Related Rates Setup Builder. The related rates guide covers the general method.
Worked examples
Worked example
Rate of the top when the foot is 60 cm out
A 100 cm ladder leans against a wall. Its foot slides away from the wall at cm per second. How fast is the top moving when the foot is cm from the wall?
- Relate the variables: , where is the distance of the foot from the wall and is the height of the top.
- Differentiate with respect to time: .
- Find the height at this instant: .
- Substitute , , : , so .
The top is moving down the wall at cm per second, so cm per second.
Worked example
Water level in a cone cup
A cone cup has top radius cm and depth cm. Water enters at mL per second. How fast is the water level rising when the water is cm deep, and when it is cm deep?
- By similar triangles the surface radius is , so .
- Differentiate with respect to time: .
- At : , so cm per second.
- At : , so cm per second.
About cm per second at a depth of cm and about cm per second at a depth of cm. Halving the depth makes the level rise four times as fast, because the rate is proportional to .
Frequently asked questions
How long does this related rates activity take?
About 40 minutes: 5 for setup, 10 for measuring, 5 to look at the data, 12 for the derivation and predictions, and 8 for discussion and the exit check.
What if I do not have enough meter sticks?
Any straight stick of known length works. Use the relation and recompute the table with . The formula does not change.
Why use a pretend clock and not a stopwatch?
Moving the foot one mark per second by hand is hard to do accurately. Treating each 10 cm move as one second keeps the rate of the foot exact, so every difference between the data and the prediction comes from measuring the height.
Do students need related rates before this lab?
No. They need the Pythagorean theorem and implicit differentiation. The lab is written to introduce related rates, with the measurements coming before the derivation.