AP Calculus AB and BC
Concavity, Inflection Points, Second Derivative Test
A graph is concave up where f'' is positive and concave down where f'' is negative. An inflection point is a point on the graph where concavity changes. The second derivative test applies where f'(c) = 0: f''(c) > 0 gives a relative minimum, f''(c) < 0 gives a relative maximum, and f''(c) = 0 is inconclusive.
What concavity measures
Concavity describes how the slope of a graph is changing. A graph is concave up on an interval where is increasing: the slopes get larger as you move right, and the curve bends upward like a cup. A graph is concave down where is decreasing, and the curve bends downward like a dome. This is CED Topic 5.6, Determining Concavity of Functions over Their Domains.
Since is the derivative of , its sign tells you whether is increasing or decreasing. That gives the working test:
| On an interval | Behavior of | Concavity of | Tangent lines |
|---|---|---|---|
| Increasing | Concave up | Lie below the graph | |
| Decreasing | Concave down | Lie above the graph |
Concavity is independent of direction. A function can be increasing and concave down (rising but leveling off) or decreasing and concave up (falling but leveling off). Direction comes from the sign of ; concavity comes from the sign of .
Finding inflection points
An inflection point is a point on the graph of where the concavity changes, from up to down or from down to up. The function has to be continuous there. To find inflection points, build a sign chart for the same way you build one for .
- Find and factor it.
- Mark every where or is undefined. These are the possible inflection points.
- Test the sign of in each interval between the marks.
- An inflection point occurs at each marked in the domain of where the sign of changes. Report it as a point if the question asks for the point.
A zero of f'' is only a candidate
does not guarantee an inflection point. For , is zero at but positive on both sides, so the graph is concave up throughout and has no inflection point. The sign of must change.
The second derivative test
The second derivative test (CED Topic 5.7, Using the Second Derivative Test to Determine Extrema) classifies a critical point using a single value of in place of a sign chart. It applies only at a point where .
| At a point with | Conclusion |
|---|---|
| Relative minimum at | |
| Relative maximum at | |
| or does not exist | No conclusion from this test |
The picture explains the rule. A horizontal tangent on a concave up curve sits at the bottom of a cup, which is a minimum. A horizontal tangent on a concave down curve sits at the top of a dome, which is a maximum. Many students remember it backward because positive sounds like maximum; think of the shape, and the signs follow.
When the test is inconclusive, the point could be a maximum, a minimum, or neither. Go back to the first derivative test and check the sign of on each side.
Writing the justification
- Concavity: the graph of is concave up on because on .
- Inflection point: the graph of has an inflection point at because changes sign at .
- Second derivative test: has a relative minimum at because and .
The second derivative test needs both facts in the sentence. Stating only that leaves out the requirement that is a point with a horizontal tangent. When you are given a graph of instead of a formula, concavity comes from whether is increasing or decreasing, and an inflection point of occurs where changes from increasing to decreasing or the reverse.
Where students lose points
- Declaring an inflection point wherever without checking for a sign change.
- Reversing the second derivative test. Positive at a critical point means a minimum.
- Using the second derivative test at a point where . The sign of there tells you about concavity only.
- Treating an inconclusive result as 'no extremum'. has and , and it has a relative minimum at .
- Mixing up the roles of the derivatives: zeros of are candidates for extrema of , and zeros of are candidates for inflection points of .
Worked examples
Worked example
Concavity intervals and inflection points
Find the intervals of concavity and the inflection points of .
- Differentiate twice: and .
- Possible inflection points: at and .
- Test each interval. . . .
- The sign of changes at both and , so both give inflection points. The heights are and .
Concave up on and ; concave down on . Inflection points at and .
Worked example
Classifying critical points with the second derivative test
Use the second derivative test to find the relative extrema of .
- Find the critical points: , so at and .
- Find the second derivative: .
- Evaluate at each critical point. , so has a relative maximum at . , so has a relative minimum at .
- Compute the values: and .
Relative maximum of at (since and ); relative minimum of at (since and ).
Worked example
When the test is inconclusive
Classify the critical points of using the second derivative test where possible.
- Find the critical points: , so at and .
- Find the second derivative: .
- At : , so has a relative minimum at , with .
- At : , so the test gives no conclusion. Switch to the first derivative test. Since for and near , is negative on both sides of . There is no sign change.
Relative minimum of at . At the second derivative test is inconclusive, and the first derivative test shows there is no relative extremum because is negative on both sides.
Frequently asked questions
Is there always an inflection point where ?
No. The second derivative must change sign. has , but is positive on both sides of , so there is no inflection point.
What does it mean when the second derivative test is inconclusive?
When and , the test cannot classify the point. It might be a minimum ( at ), a maximum ( at ), or neither ( at ). Use the first derivative test instead.
Can a function be increasing and concave down at the same time?
Yes. Increasing means and concave down means . for is an example: it rises everywhere while its slope keeps shrinking.