AP Calculus AB and BC
Derivative Graph Matching Activity: f, f' and f'' Card Sort
Students sort 18 unlabeled graph cards into six families, each holding a function, its first derivative and its second derivative. They justify every match with zeros, signs, turning points and concavity. The guide lists the 18 functions to plot, a 40-minute plan and the full key.
Objective and materials
Students connect the graph of a function to the graphs of its first and second derivatives using sign, zeros, turning points and concavity, and they state the evidence for each match in a sentence. The activity serves CED Topic 5.8, Sketching Graphs of Functions and Their Derivatives, and Topic 5.9, Connecting a Function, Its First Derivative, and Its Second Derivative.
- One set of 18 graph cards per pair or group of three, cut apart and shuffled
- A recording sheet with six rows and three columns labeled , ,
- Any graphing calculator or graphing software to make the cards ahead of time
- An envelope or paper clip per set
Students should know that a positive derivative means an increasing function and that the second derivative describes concavity. They do not need to differentiate anything: the cards carry no formulas.
Making the cards
Plot each function below in the same window, and , with gridlines and axis numbers visible and no equation shown. Print each graph with only its card number. The numbers are already scrambled so that a number gives no hint about the family or the role.
| Card | Plot this | Card | Plot this |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 10 | ||
| 2 | 11 | ||
| 3 | 12 | ||
| 4 | 13 | ||
| 5 | 14 | ||
| 6 | 15 | ||
| 7 | 16 | ||
| 8 | 17 | ||
| 9 | 18 |
Use radians for the trigonometric cards. If a printer is not available, sketch the cards by hand on index cards with a common grid, using the key features in the answer key to place zeros and turning points accurately.
A 40-minute sequence
| Minutes | Teacher move | Student evidence |
|---|---|---|
| 0 to 5 | Sketch one curve with a single peak on the board. Ask what its derivative graph must do at the peak, to the left of it and to the right of it. | Three statements: zero at the peak, positive before, negative after. |
| 5 to 10 | Hand out the cards. First task: find the six cards that could be the starting functions, and say why the others are harder to judge. | A first grouping, with reasons. |
| 10 to 28 | Groups sort all 18 cards into six rows of , , and write one piece of evidence for each link. | A completed recording sheet with twelve evidence statements. |
| 28 to 36 | Groups compare sheets with a neighboring group and settle disagreements using the cards. Then reveal the key. | Corrected rows and revised evidence. |
| 36 to 40 | Exit check. | A written exit check. |
Rules students should use as evidence
- Where is positive, is increasing. Where is negative, is decreasing.
- Where changes sign, has a local maximum (positive to negative) or a local minimum (negative to positive).
- Where is positive, is concave up and is increasing. Where is negative, is concave down and is decreasing.
- Where changes sign, has a point of inflection and has a local maximum or minimum.
Require the -value in every evidence statement. "Card 7 has a local maximum at and card 12 changes from positive to negative at " is evidence. "They look related" is not.
Answer key
| Family | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| A | Card 7: | Card 12: | Card 3: |
| B | Card 15: | Card 9: | Card 1: |
| C | Card 4: | Card 17: | Card 11: |
| D | Card 10: | Card 2: | Card 14: |
| E | Card 18: | Card 6: | Card 13: |
| F | Card 5: | Card 16: | Card 8: |
Evidence a complete answer should contain:
- Family A. Card 7 has a local maximum at and a local minimum at . Card 12 is zero at and , positive outside them and negative between them. Card 12 has its minimum at , where card 3 crosses from negative to positive, and card 7 changes from concave down to concave up at .
- Family B. Card 15 has its minimum at , where card 9 crosses from negative to positive. Card 9 is a line with slope everywhere, and card 1 has height everywhere. Card 15 is concave up everywhere, and card 1 is positive everywhere.
- Family C. Card 4 has a local maximum at and a local minimum at , which are the zeros of card 17 in that part of the window. Card 17 has its maximum at , where card 11 crosses from positive to negative. Card 4 is concave down where card 11 is negative.
- Family D. All three cards are positive, increasing and concave up, and none has a zero, so heights decide. The slope of card 10 at is , which is the height of card 2 at . The slope of card 2 at is , the height of card 14 at .
- Family E. Card 18 has local minima at and and a local maximum at . Card 6 has zeros at , and with signs negative, positive, negative, positive across the four intervals. Card 6 has a local maximum near and a local minimum near , which are the zeros of card 13.
- Family F. Card 5 has its maximum at . Card 16 is positive for and negative for . Card 16 has its maximum near and its minimum near , where card 8 is zero. Card 5 is concave down between those two values and concave up outside them.
Key features for checking printed or hand-drawn cards
| Card | Zeros | Turning points |
|---|---|---|
| 3 | None. Line with slope . | |
| 6 | Local maximum near , local minimum near | |
| 7 | and | Local maximum , local minimum |
| 8 | Minimum , maxima and | |
| 12 | Minimum | |
| 13 | Minimum | |
| 15 | Minimum | |
| 16 | Maximum near , minimum near | |
| 18 | and | Local minima , local maximum |
Cards 10, 2 and 14 cross the -axis at , and . Cards 4, 11 and 17 have amplitude . In the window, card 4 and card 11 each have zeros at and , and card 17 has zeros at .
Built-in traps and what they teach
- Cards 6 and 7 are both cubics through the origin, and cards 12 and 13 are both upward parabolas. The zeros separate them: card 7 turns at , which matches the zeros of card 12, while card 6 turns near , which matches the zeros of card 13.
- Card 3, the line , is the derivative of card 12 and also of card 13, because and differ by a constant. Only one assignment lets all 18 cards form complete families: card 18 has no card that could be its antiderivative, so it must be an , which forces cards 6 and 13 into its family and leaves card 3 for family A.
- Cards 3 and 9 are both lines through the origin. Card 9 has slope and its derivative is card 1. No card has constant height , so card 3 cannot be an or an in a complete family.
- Cards 4 and 11 are reflections of each other. Students who match by shape alone often swap them. The check is at : card 4 is increasing there, so its derivative must be positive at , and card 17 has height there.
- Family D cannot be sorted by shape at all. Students have to read slopes and heights from the grid.
Discussion questions
- If card 15 were shifted up 3 units, would it still match card 9? Answer: yes. A vertical shift adds a constant, and the derivative of a constant is zero, so the slope at every is unchanged.
- Card 7 crosses the -axis three times. Does that tell you where card 12 is zero? Answer: no. Between two zeros a smooth curve has to turn around, so card 12 must have at least two zeros, but the zeros of do not say where they are. The turning points of locate the zeros of .
- Why do all three cards in family D have the same shape? Answer: differentiating multiplies it by , so each derivative is a vertical compression of the one before.
- On card 5, the function is decreasing for but card 8 is positive for . Is that a contradiction? Answer: no. A function can decrease while concave up. The sign of describes how the slope is changing, and on that interval the slope is negative and rising toward zero.
Exit check
Without cards: the graph of is a parabola opening downward with zeros at and . State where is increasing, where has local extrema and of which kind, and where has a point of inflection.
Key: is positive between its zeros, so is increasing on and decreasing for and for . has a local minimum at (sign change negative to positive) and a local maximum at (positive to negative). The vertex of the parabola is midway between the zeros, at , where changes from increasing to decreasing, so has a point of inflection at .
Extension and follow-up
- Reverse sort: give a group only the six cards and ask for a sketch of a possible and for each, then compare with the real cards. Sketches of may differ from the cards by a vertical shift, and by a tilt as well, since is itself known only up to a constant.
- New family: each group writes a function of its own, plots the three graphs in the same window and adds them to another group's deck.
- Students can watch a derivative graph being traced point by point with the Tangent Line Tracer.
For the reasoning behind each rule, see the guides on curve sketching and concavity and the second derivative test.
Worked examples
Worked example
Justifying family A from the graphs
Cards 7, 12 and 3 show , and . Using only features visible on the graphs, explain why card 12 is the derivative of card 7 and card 3 is the derivative of card 12.
- Card 7 rises until , falls until , then rises again. Its derivative must be positive, then negative, then positive, with zeros at and . Card 12 has exactly this sign pattern.
- Card 12 falls until and rises afterward. Its derivative must be negative for , zero at and positive for . Card 3 has this sign pattern.
- Check concavity: card 7 is concave down for and concave up for , which agrees with the sign of card 3 as its second derivative.
- Confirm with the formulas: the derivative of is , and the derivative of is .
Card 7 is , card 12 is and card 3 is .
Worked example
Verifying the derivatives in family F
For , find and and locate the points of inflection of .
- Write . By the chain rule, .
- Differentiate with the product and chain rules: .
- Combine over the common denominator: .
- when , so . The numerator changes sign at each value and the denominator is always positive, so changes sign there.
and . The points of inflection are at , where .
Frequently asked questions
How many cards are in the sort?
Eighteen: six functions, their six first derivatives and their six second derivatives. For a shorter version, remove families D and F and run it with twelve cards.
Do students need to know derivative rules?
No. The cards carry graphs only, so the sort can run as soon as students know what the sign of a derivative says about a graph. The formulas are for making the cards and for the teacher key.
What window should the graphs use?
Use and on every card, with gridlines. A shared window matters because family D and the two lines can only be told apart by reading heights and slopes.
How do I check work quickly?
Compare each group's recording sheet with the six-row key, then read one evidence statement per row. A correct match without an x-value in the evidence should be sent back for revision.