AP Calculus AB and BC

Limits Classroom Activity: Tables and Graphs in Pairs

Pairs investigate six limits. One partner builds a table from the left, the other from the right, and they compare before graphing. Five limits behave as the tables suggest. The sixth, sin(pi/x) at 0, gives a table of zeros although the limit does not exist. The full key is included.

Objective and materials

Students estimate limits from tables and graphs, write each conclusion in limit notation, distinguish the value of a limit from the value of the function, and see a case where a table points to the wrong answer. The activity serves CED Topic 1.3, Estimating Limit Values from Graphs, Topic 1.4, Estimating Limit Values from Tables, and Topic 1.9, Connecting Multiple Representations of Limits.

  • One calculator per student, set to radian mode
  • One recording sheet per pair with six blank two-sided tables
  • Six function cards, one per station or all on one handout
  • Graph paper or a graphing calculator for the sketch at each station

Students need function notation and the informal idea of a limit as the value the outputs approach. No algebraic limit techniques are required. The algebra for stations 1 and 5 appears in the key for classes that already have it.

The pair protocol

  1. Partner L evaluates the function at three inputs approaching aa from the left. Partner R does the same from the right. They work without talking.
  2. Each partner writes a one-sided conclusion: the number the outputs appear to approach, or a description of what they do instead.
  3. Partners compare. If the two one-sided conclusions agree on a number, they write a two-sided limit statement. If not, they write that the limit does not exist and say why.
  4. Together they sketch the graph near x=ax=a and mark what happens at x=ax=a itself: a hole, a jump, an asymptote or something else.
  5. They swap roles for the next station.

Use the inputs a−0.1a-0.1, a−0.01a-0.01, a−0.001a-0.001 from the left and a+0.1a+0.1, a+0.01a+0.01, a+0.001a+0.001 from the right at every station. Allow about six minutes per station.

The six stations

StationFunctionApproach
1f(x)=x2−4x−2f(x)=\frac{x^2-4}{x-2}x→2x\to 2
2g(x)=sin⁡xxg(x)=\frac{\sin x}{x}x→0x\to 0
3h(x)=∣x−3∣x−3h(x)=\frac{|x-3|}{x-3}x→3x\to 3
4k(x)=1(x−1)2k(x)=\frac{1}{(x-1)^2}x→1x\to 1
5m(x)=x+1−1xm(x)=\frac{\sqrt{x+1}-1}{x}x→0x\to 0
6q(x)=sin⁡(πx)q(x)=\sin\left(\frac{\pi}{x}\right)x→0x\to 0

Run station 6 last. After pairs record their conclusion for it, give them the second set of inputs listed in the key and let them revise.

A 45-minute sequence

MinutesTeacher moveStudent evidence
0 to 4Explain the protocol with one input worked on the board for station 1. Check radian mode.Calculators in radian mode, roles assigned.
4 to 34Pairs work stations 1 through 5, about six minutes each. Circulate and check limit notation.Five two-sided tables, five conclusions, five sketches.
34 to 41Station 6. Collect conclusions from the first table by show of hands, then hand out the second set of inputs.A first conclusion and a revised conclusion.
41 to 45Whole-class summary and exit check.A written exit check.

Answer key: tables

Station 1, f(x)=x2−4x−2f(x)=\frac{x^2-4}{x-2} near 22:

xx1.91.91.991.991.9991.9992.0012.0012.012.012.12.1
f(x)f(x)3.93.93.993.993.9993.9994.0014.0014.014.014.14.1

Station 2, g(x)=sin⁡xxg(x)=\frac{\sin x}{x} near 00, in radians:

xx−0.1-0.1−0.01-0.01−0.001-0.0010.0010.0010.010.010.10.1
g(x)g(x)0.9983340.9983340.9999830.9999831.0000001.0000001.0000001.0000000.9999830.9999830.9983340.998334

The entries at ±0.001\pm 0.001 are 0.999999830.99999983 before rounding to six places. Station 3, h(x)=∣x−3∣x−3h(x)=\frac{|x-3|}{x-3} near 33:

xx2.92.92.992.992.9992.9993.0013.0013.013.013.13.1
h(x)h(x)−1-1−1-1−1-1111111

Station 4, k(x)=1(x−1)2k(x)=\frac{1}{(x-1)^2} near 11:

xx0.90.90.990.990.9990.9991.0011.0011.011.011.11.1
k(x)k(x)100100100001000010000001000000100000010000001000010000100100

Station 5, m(x)=x+1−1xm(x)=\frac{\sqrt{x+1}-1}{x} near 00:

xx−0.1-0.1−0.01-0.01−0.001-0.0010.0010.0010.010.010.10.1
m(x)m(x)0.5131670.5131670.5012560.5012560.5001250.5001250.4998750.4998750.4987560.4987560.4880880.488088

Station 6, q(x)=sin⁡(πx)q(x)=\sin\left(\frac{\pi}{x}\right) near 00, first set of inputs:

xx−0.1-0.1−0.01-0.01−0.001-0.0010.0010.0010.010.010.10.1
q(x)q(x)000000000000

Each of these inputs makes πx\frac{\pi}{x} a whole-number multiple of π\pi, where the sine is exactly 00. A calculator may show a value such as 2⋅10−132\cdot 10^{-13} in place of 00 because of rounding inside the machine. Station 6, second set of inputs:

xx25=0.4\frac{2}{5}=0.4241≈0.04878\frac{2}{41}\approx 0.04878243≈0.04651\frac{2}{43}\approx 0.046512401≈0.004988\frac{2}{401}\approx 0.0049882403≈0.004963\frac{2}{403}\approx 0.004963
q(x)q(x)1111−1-111−1-1

Have students enter the second set as fractions, for example sin⁡(π÷(2÷41))\sin(\pi\div(2\div 41)), so that rounding the input does not disturb the output.

Answer key: conclusions

  1. lim⁡x→2x2−4x−2=4\lim_{x\to 2}\frac{x^2-4}{x-2}=4. The function is undefined at x=2x=2, and the graph is the line y=x+2y=x+2 with a hole at (2,4)(2,4). For x≠2x\ne 2, x2−4x−2=(x−2)(x+2)x−2=x+2\frac{x^2-4}{x-2}=\frac{(x-2)(x+2)}{x-2}=x+2.
  2. lim⁡x→0sin⁡xx=1\lim_{x\to 0}\frac{\sin x}{x}=1. The function is undefined at 00 and its graph has a hole at (0,1)(0,1). The left and right tables match because sin⁡xx\frac{\sin x}{x} is an even function.
  3. lim⁡x→3−h(x)=−1\lim_{x\to 3^-}h(x)=-1 and lim⁡x→3+h(x)=1\lim_{x\to 3^+}h(x)=1. The one-sided limits differ, so lim⁡x→3h(x)\lim_{x\to 3}h(x) does not exist. The graph has a jump at x=3x=3.
  4. The outputs grow without bound from both sides, so no real number is the limit. This behavior is written lim⁡x→11(x−1)2=∞\lim_{x\to 1}\frac{1}{(x-1)^2}=\infty, and the graph has a vertical asymptote at x=1x=1.
  5. lim⁡x→0x+1−1x=12\lim_{x\to 0}\frac{\sqrt{x+1}-1}{x}=\frac{1}{2}. The left values decrease toward 0.50.5 and the right values increase toward 0.50.5. Multiplying numerator and denominator by x+1+1\sqrt{x+1}+1 gives 1x+1+1\frac{1}{\sqrt{x+1}+1} for x≠0x\ne 0, which approaches 12\frac{1}{2}.
  6. lim⁡x→0sin⁡(πx)\lim_{x\to 0}\sin\left(\frac{\pi}{x}\right) does not exist. The first table suggests 00, but the second shows outputs of 11 and −1-1 at inputs just as close to 00. The function oscillates between −1-1 and 11 infinitely often as xx approaches 00 and approaches no single value.

What students should notice

  • At stations 1, 2 and 5 the function has no value at aa, yet the limit exists. A limit describes nearby outputs and ignores the output at aa.
  • At station 3 each partner had a clear answer and the two answers disagreed. A two-sided limit needs both sides to agree.
  • At station 4 both sides agree in behavior, and the behavior is growth without bound.
  • At station 6 a table with a regular pattern of inputs sampled the function only where it is 00. A table is evidence for a limit and can mislead. A graph or an argument is needed to settle it.

If station 2 gives 0.017453

A table for sin⁡xx\frac{\sin x}{x} whose entries are all close to 0.0174530.017453 means the calculator is in degree mode. That number is π180\frac{\pi}{180}. Switch to radians and repeat.

Discussion questions

  1. At station 1, a student says the limit cannot be 44 because f(2)f(2) does not exist. Respond. Answer: the limit asks what f(x)f(x) approaches as xx gets close to 22, with x≠2x\ne 2. The table shows outputs within 0.0010.001 of 44 when xx is within 0.0010.001 of 22, and the simplified form x+2x+2 confirms it.
  2. Stations 3 and 4 both lack a finite limit. How are they different? Answer: at station 3 each side has a finite limit and the two differ. At station 4 neither side approaches a real number, because the outputs increase without bound.
  3. How could you choose inputs for station 6 that make the table show −1-1 every time? Answer: choose xx so that πx\frac{\pi}{x} equals 3π2\frac{3\pi}{2} plus a multiple of 2π2\pi, for example x=23x=\frac{2}{3}, 27\frac{2}{7}, 211\frac{2}{11}, 243\frac{2}{43}.
  4. Which stations could be made continuous at aa by defining one extra value? Answer: stations 1, 2 and 5, by defining the value at aa to be the limit: 44, 11 and 12\frac{1}{2}.

Exit check

A table for a function pp shows p(4.9)=7.2p(4.9)=7.2, p(4.99)=7.02p(4.99)=7.02, p(4.999)=7.002p(4.999)=7.002, p(5.001)=2.998p(5.001)=2.998, p(5.01)=2.98p(5.01)=2.98, p(5.1)=2.8p(5.1)=2.8, and p(5)=7p(5)=7. Write the best estimates for the left-hand limit, the right-hand limit and the two-sided limit at 55, and say whether the value p(5)p(5) affects any of them.

Key: the table suggests lim⁡x→5−p(x)=7\lim_{x\to 5^-}p(x)=7 and lim⁡x→5+p(x)=3\lim_{x\to 5^+}p(x)=3. These differ, so lim⁡x→5p(x)\lim_{x\to 5}p(x) does not exist. The value p(5)=7p(5)=7 plays no role in any of the three.

Extension and follow-up

  • Squeeze preview: add the function xsin⁡(πx)x\sin\left(\frac{\pi}{x}\right) at 00. Its outputs lie between −∣x∣-|x| and ∣x∣|x|, so they are forced toward 00, and this limit is 00 even though sin⁡(πx)\sin\left(\frac{\pi}{x}\right) alone has no limit. The squeeze theorem guide gives the full argument.
  • Method choice: for stations 1 through 5, ask which algebraic method would confirm the table, then check with the limit method chooser.
  • Vocabulary: classify the behavior at each station as a removable discontinuity, a jump, a vertical asymptote or an oscillation, using the continuity and discontinuities guide.

The guide on how to find limits covers the algebraic methods that follow this activity.

Worked examples

Worked example

A two-sided table for a removable discontinuity

Estimate lim⁡x→2x2−4x−2\lim_{x\to 2}\frac{x^2-4}{x-2} from a table, then confirm it algebraically.

  1. From the left: f(1.9)=3.61−4−0.1=3.9f(1.9)=\frac{3.61-4}{-0.1}=3.9, f(1.99)=3.99f(1.99)=3.99, f(1.999)=3.999f(1.999)=3.999.
  2. From the right: f(2.1)=4.41−40.1=4.1f(2.1)=\frac{4.41-4}{0.1}=4.1, f(2.01)=4.01f(2.01)=4.01, f(2.001)=4.001f(2.001)=4.001.
  3. Both sides approach 44, so the table suggests the limit is 44.
  4. Confirm: for x≠2x\ne 2, x2−4x−2=(x−2)(x+2)x−2=x+2\frac{x^2-4}{x-2}=\frac{(x-2)(x+2)}{x-2}=x+2, and x+2x+2 approaches 44 as xx approaches 22.

lim⁡x→2x2−4x−2=4\lim_{x\to 2}\frac{x^2-4}{x-2}=4, although f(2)f(2) is undefined.

Worked example

Why the table for station 6 shows only zeros

Explain why sin⁡(πx)\sin\left(\frac{\pi}{x}\right) equals 00 at x=0.1x=0.1, 0.010.01 and 0.0010.001, and find inputs closer to 00 than 0.010.01 where it equals 11 and −1-1.

  1. At x=0.1x=0.1, πx=10π\frac{\pi}{x}=10\pi. At x=0.01x=0.01 it is 100π100\pi, and at x=0.001x=0.001 it is 1000π1000\pi. The sine of any whole-number multiple of π\pi is 00.
  2. The sine equals 11 when its input is π2\frac{\pi}{2} plus a multiple of 2π2\pi. Take πx=401π2=200π+π2\frac{\pi}{x}=\frac{401\pi}{2}=200\pi+\frac{\pi}{2}, so x=2401≈0.004988x=\frac{2}{401}\approx 0.004988.
  3. The sine equals −1-1 when its input is 3π2\frac{3\pi}{2} plus a multiple of 2π2\pi. Take πx=403π2=200π+3π2\frac{\pi}{x}=\frac{403\pi}{2}=200\pi+\frac{3\pi}{2}, so x=2403≈0.004963x=\frac{2}{403}\approx 0.004963.
  4. Inputs of this kind exist as close to 00 as we like, so the outputs keep returning to 11, −1-1 and 00.

The first table sampled only inputs where πx\frac{\pi}{x} is a multiple of π\pi. Because q(2401)=1q\left(\frac{2}{401}\right)=1 and q(2403)=−1q\left(\frac{2}{403}\right)=-1, with similar inputs arbitrarily close to 00, the limit does not exist.

Frequently asked questions

How long does the limits activity take?

About 45 minutes: 4 to explain the protocol, 30 for five stations, 7 for the sixth station and its second table, and 4 for the summary and exit check.

Do students need limit laws or factoring first?

No. The activity uses only tables and graphs, so it fits early in Unit 1. The algebra in the key is there for classes that want to confirm the estimates.

Can it run without graphing calculators?

Yes. A scientific calculator handles every table. Students can sketch stations 1, 3 and 4 by hand, and the teacher can display graphs for stations 2, 5 and 6.

Why include a table that gives the wrong impression?

Students tend to treat a table as proof. Station 6 shows that a table samples only the inputs chosen, and that a pattern in the inputs can hide the behavior of the function.