AP Calculus AB and BC

Curve Sketching: Connecting Graphs of f, f', and f''

The sign of f' tells you where f increases or decreases, and the sign of f'' tells you where f is concave up or down. On a graph of f', the zeros where f' changes sign are the relative extrema of f, and the turning points of f' are the inflection points of f. Always check which graph you were given before reading it.

One translation table for three graphs

Every feature of the graph of ff shows up as a different feature on the graphs of f′f' and f′′f''. CED Topics 5.8 (Sketching Graphs of Functions and Their Derivatives) and 5.9 (Connecting a Function, Its First Derivative, and Its Second Derivative) are about moving between the three. The table below is the whole dictionary.

Feature of ffOn the graph of f′f'On the graph of f′′f''
Increasingf′f' is above the xx-axisNot determined by f′′f''
Decreasingf′f' is below the xx-axisNot determined by f′′f''
Relative maximumf′f' crosses the axis from above to belowNot determined by f′′f''
Relative minimumf′f' crosses the axis from below to aboveNot determined by f′′f''
Concave upf′f' is increasingf′′f'' is above the xx-axis
Concave downf′f' is decreasingf′′f'' is below the xx-axis
Inflection pointf′f' has a relative maximum or minimumf′′f'' changes sign

Each row is a fact you already know, written in graph language. A relative maximum of ff is where f′f' changes from positive to negative, and on a graph that is a downward crossing of the xx-axis. Concave up means f′f' is increasing, and on the graph of f′f' that is a stretch where the curve rises.

Reading a graph of f'

The most common version of this task gives you the graph of f′f' and asks about ff. The first step is to notice that the graph is the derivative and to say so in your work. Then read two things from it: its height and its direction.

  • Height of f′f' (above or below the axis) gives the direction of ff. Where the graph of f′f' is above the axis, ff is increasing. Where it is below, ff is decreasing.
  • Zeros of f′f', and any points where f′f' is undefined but ff is defined, are the critical points of ff. Classify each one by how f′f' crosses the axis. If the graph of f′f' touches the axis and turns back without crossing, ff has no extremum there.
  • Direction of f′f' (rising or falling) gives the concavity of ff. Where the graph of f′f' is rising, ff is concave up. Where it is falling, ff is concave down.
  • Peaks and valleys of f′f' are the inflection points of ff, because that is where f′f' switches between increasing and decreasing.

The classic misread

A high point on the graph of f′f' is where the slope of ff is greatest (where ff is increasing fastest, if f′f' is positive there), and it marks an inflection point of ff. The maximum of ff is where f′f' crosses the axis going down.

Sketching f from a formula

When you have a formula and need a sketch, collect the information in a fixed order so nothing is missed.

  1. Domain and intercepts. Note any xx where ff is undefined, then find f(0)f(0) and the zeros of ff if they are easy to get.
  2. Asymptotes and end behavior, from limits at infinity and at points where ff is undefined.
  3. First derivative. Find the critical points and make a sign chart for f′f' to get the increasing and decreasing intervals and the relative extrema.
  4. Second derivative. Make a sign chart for f′′f'' to get the concavity intervals and the inflection points.
  5. Plot the key points (intercepts, extrema, inflection points) and connect them with the direction and concavity from the two charts.

The two sign charts combine into four shapes. Increasing and concave up is a curve rising and getting steeper. Increasing and concave down rises while flattening. Decreasing and concave up falls while flattening. Decreasing and concave down falls and gets steeper.

Going from f to f'

To sketch f′f' from a graph of ff, reverse the table. Estimate slopes of ff and plot them as heights.

  1. Mark the xx-values where ff has a horizontal tangent. The graph of f′f' has zeros there.
  2. Where ff is increasing, draw f′f' above the axis. Where ff is decreasing, draw f′f' below it.
  3. Mark the inflection points of ff. The graph of f′f' has a relative maximum or minimum at each one.
  4. Where ff is concave up, f′f' rises. Where ff is concave down, f′f' falls.
  5. Where ff has a corner or a vertical tangent, f′f' is undefined; leave a gap or an open circle.

The height of ff plays no role. Shifting a graph up or down changes none of its slopes, so f(x)f(x) and f(x)+5f(x) + 5 have the same derivative graph.

Where students lose points

  • Reading the graph of f′f' as if it were ff: reporting where f′f' is increasing when the question asks where ff is increasing.
  • Placing a relative extremum of ff at a peak of f′f' instead of at a sign change of f′f'.
  • Counting a zero of f′f' as an extremum of ff when the graph of f′f' only touches the axis.
  • Placing an inflection point of ff at a zero of f′f'. Inflection points of ff come from extrema of f′f', which are sign changes of f′′f''.
  • Justifying with the wrong function. If the given graph is f′f', the reasons must be stated in terms of f′f': its sign for direction, its increasing or decreasing behavior for concavity.

Worked examples

Worked example

Reading f from a graph of f'

The graph of f′f' on [0,6][0, 6] consists of two line segments: one from (0,2)(0, 2) to (4,−2)(4, -2) and one from (4,−2)(4, -2) to (6,0)(6, 0). Find where ff is increasing, where ff has a relative extremum, where the graph of ff is concave up, and the xx-coordinate of any inflection point of ff on (0,6)(0, 6).

  1. Find where f′f' is zero. The first segment has slope −2−24−0=−1\frac{-2 - 2}{4 - 0} = -1, so f′(x)=2−xf'(x) = 2 - x on [0,4][0, 4] and f′(2)=0f'(2) = 0. The second segment has slope 0−(−2)6−4=1\frac{0 - (-2)}{6 - 4} = 1 and reaches zero only at the endpoint x=6x = 6.
  2. Read the sign of f′f'. The graph is above the axis on (0,2)(0, 2) and below it on (2,6)(2, 6). So ff is increasing on (0,2)(0, 2) and decreasing on (2,6)(2, 6).
  3. Classify the critical point. At x=2x = 2, f′f' changes from positive to negative, so ff has a relative maximum at x=2x = 2.
  4. Read the direction of f′f'. The graph of f′f' is falling on (0,4)(0, 4) and rising on (4,6)(4, 6). So the graph of ff is concave down on (0,4)(0, 4) and concave up on (4,6)(4, 6).
  5. Locate the inflection point. f′f' changes from decreasing to increasing at x=4x = 4, so the graph of ff has an inflection point at x=4x = 4.

ff is increasing on (0,2)(0, 2) and has a relative maximum at x=2x = 2. The graph of ff is concave up on (4,6)(4, 6) and has an inflection point at x=4x = 4.

Worked example

A full sketch from a formula

Find the intercepts, relative extrema, and inflection point of f(x)=x3−3x2f(x) = x^3 - 3x^2, and describe the shape of the graph.

  1. Intercepts: f(x)=x2(x−3)f(x) = x^2(x - 3), so the graph meets the xx-axis at x=0x = 0 and x=3x = 3, and f(0)=0f(0) = 0. As x→∞x \to \infty, f(x)→∞f(x) \to \infty; as x→−∞x \to -\infty, f(x)→−∞f(x) \to -\infty.
  2. First derivative: f′(x)=3x2−6x=3x(x−2)f'(x) = 3x^2 - 6x = 3x(x - 2), zero at x=0x = 0 and x=2x = 2. Signs: f′(−1)=9>0f'(-1) = 9 > 0, f′(1)=−3<0f'(1) = -3 < 0, f′(3)=9>0f'(3) = 9 > 0. So ff is increasing on (−∞,0)(-\infty, 0), decreasing on (0,2)(0, 2), and increasing on (2,∞)(2, \infty).
  3. Relative extrema: f′f' changes from positive to negative at x=0x = 0, giving a relative maximum at (0,0)(0, 0). f′f' changes from negative to positive at x=2x = 2, giving a relative minimum at (2,f(2))=(2,8−12)=(2,−4)(2, f(2)) = (2, 8 - 12) = (2, -4).
  4. Second derivative: f′′(x)=6x−6f''(x) = 6x - 6, zero at x=1x = 1, negative for x<1x < 1 and positive for x>1x > 1. The graph is concave down on (−∞,1)(-\infty, 1) and concave up on (1,∞)(1, \infty), with an inflection point at (1,f(1))=(1,1−3)=(1,−2)(1, f(1)) = (1, 1 - 3) = (1, -2).

The graph rises to a relative maximum at (0,0)(0, 0), falls through the inflection point (1,−2)(1, -2) to a relative minimum at (2,−4)(2, -4), then rises through the xx-intercept at (3,0)(3, 0). It is concave down to the left of x=1x = 1 and concave up to the right.

Worked example

Describing f' and f'' from the features of f

A twice-differentiable function ff is increasing on (−∞,−1)(-\infty, -1), decreasing on (−1,3)(-1, 3), and increasing on (3,∞)(3, \infty). Its graph is concave down on (−∞,1)(-\infty, 1) and concave up on (1,∞)(1, \infty). Describe the graphs of f′f' and f′′f''.

  1. Zeros of f′f': ff is differentiable and has a relative maximum at x=−1x = -1 and a relative minimum at x=3x = 3, so f′(−1)=0f'(-1) = 0 and f′(3)=0f'(3) = 0.
  2. Sign of f′f': positive where ff increases, so the graph of f′f' is above the axis on (−∞,−1)(-\infty, -1) and (3,∞)(3, \infty), and below the axis on (−1,3)(-1, 3).
  3. Direction of f′f': ff is concave down on (−∞,1)(-\infty, 1), so f′f' is decreasing there. ff is concave up on (1,∞)(1, \infty), so f′f' is increasing there. That puts a relative minimum of f′f' at x=1x = 1.
  4. Sign of f′′f'': negative on (−∞,1)(-\infty, 1) and positive on (1,∞)(1, \infty). Because f′f' is differentiable and has a relative minimum at x=1x = 1, f′′(1)=0f''(1) = 0.

The graph of f′f' crosses the xx-axis downward at x=−1x = -1, falls to a relative minimum at x=1x = 1 (below the axis), then rises and crosses the axis upward at x=3x = 3. The graph of f′′f'' is below the axis for x<1x < 1, zero at x=1x = 1, and above the axis for x>1x > 1.

Frequently asked questions

How do I find inflection points of f from the graph of f'?

Look for the relative maxima and minima of the f′f' graph. An inflection point of ff occurs where f′f' changes from increasing to decreasing or from decreasing to increasing, because that is where f′′f'' changes sign.

How do I find relative extrema of f from the graph of f'?

Find where the graph of f′f' crosses the xx-axis. A crossing from above to below is a relative maximum of ff; a crossing from below to above is a relative minimum. If the graph of f′f' touches the axis without crossing, ff has no extremum there.

Given three unlabeled graphs, how do I tell which is f, f', and f''?

Match features using the table. Wherever one graph has a relative maximum or minimum with a smooth turn, its derivative must be zero at that xx. Wherever one graph is increasing, its derivative must be above the axis. Test a candidate pairing at two or three xx-values; the wrong pairing fails quickly.