AP Calculus AB and BC

Calculus Vertical Whiteboard Tasks: 6 Thin-Sliced Ladders

Six task ladders for groups of three at vertical whiteboards. Each has eight steps that change one feature at a time, with every answer and a note on what changed. Topics: limits by algebra, chain rule, implicit differentiation, relative extrema, substitution and area between curves. Plan about 35 minutes each.

Setup: groups, boards and time

Each ladder below is a sequence of eight tasks on one topic. Each task differs from the one before it in one feature, so a group that solved step 3 can attempt step 4 without a new explanation. This is the thin-slicing idea from Peter Liljedahl's Building Thinking Classrooms: students stand in random groups of three at a vertical erasable surface, share one marker, and receive the next task when they finish the last.

  • Surfaces: whiteboards, windows or erasable sheets on the wall, one per group of three
  • One marker per group. The student holding the marker writes only what the other two say, and the marker changes hands at every step
  • Random groups, made visibly, with cards or a shuffled class list
  • Time: 20 to 25 minutes for a ladder, then 10 minutes to consolidate at the board
  • No calculators

Give step 1 aloud. Give each later step to a group when it finishes, by saying it, writing it on the group's board, or pointing to a strip of paper taped beside the board. Do not project the whole ladder. A group that sees all eight steps tends to split them up and stop talking.

The six ladders cover limits by algebra, the chain rule, implicit differentiation, relative extrema, substitution, and area between curves. Not every group reaches step 8. Step 6 is a reasonable target for the whole class.

Ladders 1 and 2: limits by algebra and the chain rule

Ladder 1. Find each limit as x→2x\to 2. Use it during Topic 1.6, Determining Limits Using Algebraic Manipulation.

StepTaskAnswerWhat changed
1lim⁡x→2(x2+1)\lim_{x\to 2}\left(x^2+1\right)55Starting point: direct substitution works.
2lim⁡x→2x2−4x+2\lim_{x\to 2}\frac{x^2-4}{x+2}00A quotient, but substitution still works.
3lim⁡x→2x2−4x−2\lim_{x\to 2}\frac{x^2-4}{x-2}44Substitution gives 00\frac{0}{0}. Factor and cancel.
4lim⁡x→2x2−5x+6x−2\lim_{x\to 2}\frac{x^2-5x+6}{x-2}−1-1A trinomial to factor.
5lim⁡x→2x3−8x−2\lim_{x\to 2}\frac{x^3-8}{x-2}1212A difference of cubes.
6lim⁡x→2x+2−2x−2\lim_{x\to 2}\frac{\sqrt{x+2}-2}{x-2}14\frac{1}{4}A radical. Multiply by the conjugate.
7lim⁡x→21x−12x−2\lim_{x\to 2}\frac{\frac{1}{x}-\frac{1}{2}}{x-2}−14-\frac{1}{4}A complex fraction. Combine over a common denominator.
8lim⁡x→2x−2∣x−2∣\lim_{x\to 2}\frac{x-2}{|x-2|}Does not existNo algebra fixes it. The left limit is −1-1 and the right limit is 11.

Ladder 2. Differentiate each function. Use it during Topic 3.1, The Chain Rule.

StepTaskAnswerWhat changed
1(3x+1)2(3x+1)^26(3x+1)6(3x+1)Starting point. Groups can check by expanding.
2(3x+1)5(3x+1)^515(3x+1)415(3x+1)^4The power is too large to expand.
3(x2+1)5\left(x^2+1\right)^510x(x2+1)410x\left(x^2+1\right)^4The inner derivative is no longer a constant.
4x2+1\sqrt{x^2+1}xx2+1\frac{x}{\sqrt{x^2+1}}The outer function is a root.
5sin⁡(x2+1)\sin\left(x^2+1\right)2xcos⁡(x2+1)2x\cos\left(x^2+1\right)The outer function is trigonometric.
6sin⁡3x\sin^3 x3sin⁡2xcos⁡x3\sin^2 x\cos xThe trigonometric function moves to the inside.
7sin⁡3(2x)\sin^3(2x)6sin⁡2(2x)cos⁡(2x)6\sin^2(2x)\cos(2x)Three layers.
8xex2xe^{x^2}ex2+2x2ex2e^{x^2}+2x^2e^{x^2}A product with a chain rule inside it.

Ladders 3 and 4: implicit differentiation and relative extrema

Ladder 3. Find dydx\frac{dy}{dx}. Use it during Topic 3.2, Implicit Differentiation.

StepTaskAnswerWhat changed
1x2+y=5x^2+y=5−2x-2xStarting point. Groups can solve for yy first to check.
2x2+y2=25x^2+y^2=25−xy-\frac{x}{y}yy is squared, so the chain rule produces dydx\frac{dy}{dx}.
3x2+3y2=12x^2+3y^2=12−x3y-\frac{x}{3y}A coefficient on the yy term.
4x3+y3=9x^3+y^3=9−x2y2-\frac{x^2}{y^2}Higher powers.
5xy=6xy=6−yx-\frac{y}{x}A product of xx and yy.
6x2+xy+y2=7x^2+xy+y^2=7−2x+yx+2y-\frac{2x+y}{x+2y}Two terms contain dydx\frac{dy}{dx}, so it must be factored out.
7sin⁡y=x\sin y=x1cos⁡y\frac{1}{\cos y}A trigonometric function of yy.
8The slope of x2+xy+y2=7x^2+xy+y^2=7 at (1,2)(1,2)−45-\frac{4}{5}Evaluate the result of step 6 at a point.

Ladder 4. Find the xx value of every relative extremum and say whether it is a maximum or a minimum. Use it during Topic 5.4, Using the First Derivative Test to Determine Relative (Local) Extrema.

StepTaskAnswerWhat changed
1f(x)=x2−4xf(x)=x^2-4xMinimum at x=2x=2Starting point. Groups can check with the vertex.
2f(x)=−x2+6xf(x)=-x^2+6xMaximum at x=3x=3The parabola opens down.
3f(x)=x3−3xf(x)=x^3-3xMaximum at x=−1x=-1, minimum at x=1x=1Two critical points.
4f(x)=x3−3x2f(x)=x^3-3x^2Maximum at x=0x=0, minimum at x=2x=2A critical point at zero.
5f(x)=x3f(x)=x^3Nonef′(0)=0f'(0)=0 but f′f' does not change sign.
6f(x)=x4−4x3f(x)=x^4-4x^3Minimum at x=3x=3 onlyTwo critical points, and only one is an extremum. f′(x)=4x2(x−3)f'(x)=4x^2(x-3).
7f(x)=xexf(x)=xe^xMinimum at x=−1x=-1Not a polynomial. f′(x)=(x+1)exf'(x)=(x+1)e^x.
8f(x)=x−2sin⁡xf(x)=x-2\sin x on (0,2π)(0,2\pi)Minimum at x=π3x=\frac{\pi}{3}, maximum at x=5π3x=\frac{5\pi}{3}A trigonometric equation. f′(x)=1−2cos⁡xf'(x)=1-2\cos x.

Ladders 5 and 6: substitution and area between curves

Ladder 5. Find each integral. Use it during Topic 6.9, Integrating Using Substitution.

StepTaskAnswerWhat changed
1∫2x(x2+1)4dx\int 2x\left(x^2+1\right)^4dx(x2+1)55+C\frac{\left(x^2+1\right)^5}{5}+CStarting point. dudu is exactly present.
2∫x(x2+1)4dx\int x\left(x^2+1\right)^4dx(x2+1)510+C\frac{\left(x^2+1\right)^5}{10}+CA constant factor is missing.
3∫x2(x3+1)4dx\int x^2\left(x^3+1\right)^4dx(x3+1)515+C\frac{\left(x^3+1\right)^5}{15}+CA different inner function.
4∫xx2+1 dx\int\frac{x}{\sqrt{x^2+1}}\,dxx2+1+C\sqrt{x^2+1}+CThe power is negative and fractional.
5∫xx2+1 dx\int\frac{x}{x^2+1}\,dx12ln⁡(x2+1)+C\frac{1}{2}\ln\left(x^2+1\right)+CThe power is −1-1, so the answer is a logarithm.
6∫cos⁡x esin⁡x dx\int\cos x\,e^{\sin x}\,dxesin⁡x+Ce^{\sin x}+CThe inner function is trigonometric.
7∫(ln⁡x)2x dx\int\frac{(\ln x)^2}{x}\,dx(ln⁡x)33+C\frac{(\ln x)^3}{3}+Cdudu is hidden in the denominator.
8∫01x(x2+1)4dx\int_0^1 x\left(x^2+1\right)^4dx3110\frac{31}{10}Step 2 with limits. In uu the limits are 11 and 22.

Ladder 6. Find the area of each region. Use it during Topic 8.4, Finding the Area Between Curves Expressed as Functions of x, and Topic 8.5, Finding the Area Between Curves Expressed as Functions of y.

StepTaskAnswerWhat changed
1Under y=x2y=x^2 from x=0x=0 to x=2x=283\frac{8}{3}Starting point: area under one curve.
2Between y=4y=4 and y=x2y=x^2 from x=0x=0 to x=2x=2163\frac{16}{3}Top curve minus bottom curve.
3The whole region between y=4y=4 and y=x2y=x^2323\frac{32}{3}Groups must find the limits themselves.
4Between y=xy=x and y=x2y=x^216\frac{1}{6}Both boundaries are curves that vary.
5Between y=2xy=2x and y=x2y=x^243\frac{4}{3}New intersection points.
6Between y=x+2y=x+2 and y=x2y=x^292\frac{9}{2}A negative lower limit.
7Between y=x3y=x^3 and y=xy=x12\frac{1}{2}The curves cross at x=0x=0, so the top curve switches.
8Between x=y2x=y^2 and x=y+2x=y+292\frac{9}{2}Integrate in yy: right curve minus left curve.

Steps 6 and 8 of ladder 6 have the same answer. Ask a group that finishes why: the second region is the first one reflected across the line y=xy=x.

Hints, checks and extensions

While groups work, the job is to keep every group thinking without doing the thinking for them. Three moves cover most situations.

SituationMove
A group is stuck and asks what to doAnswer with a question about the previous step: what did you do in step 3, and what is different now? Then walk away.
A group asks whether its answer is rightPoint them to a group at the same step and have the two groups compare. Confirm only if they still disagree.
A group has a wrong answer and has moved onGive them the next step anyway. If the error repeats, ask them to explain step by step to a neighboring group.
One student is holding the marker and doing all the workHand the marker to the quietest student and restate the rule: the writer writes only what the others say.

A group that finishes step 8 early gets the extension for that ladder.

LadderExtension taskAnswer
1lim⁡x→2x2−4x+2−2\lim_{x\to 2}\frac{x^2-4}{\sqrt{x+2}-2}1616
2Differentiate sin⁡(cos⁡(x2))\sin\left(\cos\left(x^2\right)\right).−2xsin⁡(x2)cos⁡(cos⁡(x2))-2x\sin\left(x^2\right)\cos\left(\cos\left(x^2\right)\right)
3Find d2ydx2\frac{d^2y}{dx^2} for x2+y2=25x^2+y^2=25 in terms of yy.−25y3-\frac{25}{y^3}
4Find and classify the relative extrema of f(x)=x2e−xf(x)=x^2e^{-x}.Minimum at x=0x=0, maximum at x=2x=2, since f′(x)=x(2−x)e−xf'(x)=x(2-x)e^{-x}
5∫xx+1 dx\int x\sqrt{x+1}\,dx25(x+1)5/2−23(x+1)3/2+C\frac{2}{5}(x+1)^{5/2}-\frac{2}{3}(x+1)^{3/2}+C
6The area between y=sin⁡xy=\sin x and y=cos⁡xy=\cos x from x=0x=0 to x=π2x=\frac{\pi}{2}22−22\sqrt{2}-2

Consolidating after a ladder

Stop the room when most groups have passed step 6. Students stay standing and turn to one board. Work through three steps from the ladder at the front, chosen in advance: the first step where the method changed, the step most groups slowed down on, and the last step most groups reached. Ask the groups, not yourself, to say what changed at each one.

Then students sit and write their own notes for five minutes: one worked example from an early step, one from a late step, and one sentence that begins with the words watch out for. These notes replace the notes you would have given in a lecture, and students write them after they have done the problems, not before.

LadderSteps to consolidateThe sentence to listen for
13, 6, 800\frac{0}{0} means rewrite the expression, and a limit can still fail to exist.
23, 6, 8Differentiate the outside, keep the inside, multiply by the derivative of the inside.
32, 5, 6Every yy term produces a dydx\frac{dy}{dx}, including inside a product.
43, 5, 6A critical point is an extremum only if f′f' changes sign.
52, 5, 8Choose uu so that dudu is in the integrand up to a constant, and change the limits.
63, 7, 8Find the intersections first, and check which curve is on top or on the right.

For the day after a ladder, a matching prerequisite or compute item from the warm-ups by unit checks what stayed. The chain rule guide, the u-substitution guide and the area between curves guide give students a written reference for ladders 2, 5 and 6.

Worked examples

Worked example

Ladder 1, step 7

Find lim⁡x→21x−12x−2\lim_{x\to 2}\frac{\frac{1}{x}-\frac{1}{2}}{x-2}.

  1. Substitution gives 00\frac{0}{0}. Combine the numerator over the common denominator 2x2x: 1x−12=2−x2x\frac{1}{x}-\frac{1}{2}=\frac{2-x}{2x}.
  2. The expression is 2−x2x(x−2)\frac{2-x}{2x(x-2)}. Since 2−x=−(x−2)2-x=-(x-2), it simplifies to −12x-\frac{1}{2x} for x≠2x\ne 2.
  3. Substitute x=2x=2: −14-\frac{1}{4}.

The limit is −14-\frac{1}{4}.

Worked example

Ladder 6, step 7

Find the area of the region between y=x3y=x^3 and y=xy=x.

  1. The curves meet where x3=xx^3=x: at x=−1x=-1, x=0x=0 and x=1x=1.
  2. On [0,1][0,1] the line is on top: ∫01(x−x3)dx=12−14=14\int_0^1\left(x-x^3\right)dx=\frac{1}{2}-\frac{1}{4}=\frac{1}{4}.
  3. On [−1,0][-1,0] the cubic is on top: ∫−10(x3−x)dx=14\int_{-1}^0\left(x^3-x\right)dx=\frac{1}{4}.
  4. Add the two pieces. The single integral ∫−11(x−x3)dx\int_{-1}^1\left(x-x^3\right)dx equals 00, which is not the area.

The area is 12\frac{1}{2}.

Frequently asked questions

What is thin slicing in a math class?

A sequence of tasks in which each one differs from the last in a single feature, so students can attempt it without new instruction. The term comes from Peter Liljedahl's Building Thinking Classrooms. Each ladder on this page is a thin-sliced sequence of eight tasks.

How long does one vertical whiteboard task ladder take?

Plan 20 to 25 minutes of group work and 10 minutes of consolidation. Step 6 is a reasonable target in that time, and faster groups can reach step 8 and an extension.

Do I need whiteboards on every wall?

No. Windows, laminated poster sheets and erasable wall film all work. What matters is that the surface is vertical and erasable, that each group of three has one marker, and that groups can see each other's work.