AP Calculus AB and BC

AP Calculus Error Analysis: 12 Find-the-Mistake Tasks

Twelve short worked solutions for AP Calculus, each with exactly one wrong line. Students name the line, explain the mistake in a sentence and fix it. The key gives the wrong line, the reason and the corrected answer for all twelve, with three BC swaps, four ways to run the tasks and a three-point scoring scale.

How to run the tasks

Each task is a short worked solution with exactly one wrong line. Every line after the wrong one follows correctly from it, so the final answer looks reasonable and students cannot find the error by checking arithmetic at the end. For each task a student writes four things: the number of the wrong line, what the writer did, one sentence on why it is wrong, and the corrected work.

FormatTimeSetup
Pairs, four tasks25 minutesPrint one group of four tasks per pair. Pairs agree on the wrong line before writing anything.
Gallery, all twelve45 minutesPost the twelve tasks around the room. Pairs visit each for three minutes with a recording sheet.
One a day5 minutesProject one task as the opener for twelve class days.
Quiz15 minutesFour tasks, individual, graded on the three-point scale below.

A three-point scale works for any format: one point for the right line, one for a correct sentence about why it is wrong, one for the corrected answer. Students tend to skip the sentence, so do not accept a correction without it.

  • Materials: the tasks printed one per half page, a recording sheet with four columns, and the key in the fifth section
  • Prerequisite: the unit each task comes from. Tasks 1 to 4 need Units 1 to 3, tasks 5 to 8 need Units 3 to 5, and tasks 9 to 12 need Units 6 to 8

Tasks 1 to 4: limits and derivative rules

Task 1. Find lim⁡x→3x2−9x−3\lim_{x\to 3}\frac{x^2-9}{x-3}.

  1. Substitute x=3x=3: 9−93−3=00\frac{9-9}{3-3}=\frac{0}{0}.
  2. The expression 00\frac{0}{0} is not a number.
  3. So the limit does not exist.

Task 2. Differentiate y=sin⁡(3x2)y=\sin\left(3x^2\right).

  1. The outer function is sine and the inner function is 3x23x^2.
  2. The derivative of sine is cosine.
  3. So y′=cos⁡(3x2)y'=\cos\left(3x^2\right).

Task 3. Differentiate f(x)=x2exf(x)=x^2e^x.

  1. ff is the product of x2x^2 and exe^x.
  2. The derivatives of the factors are 2x2x and exe^x.
  3. So f′(x)=2x⋅ex=2xexf'(x)=2x\cdot e^x=2xe^x.

Task 4. Differentiate f(x)=xx2+1f(x)=\frac{x}{x^2+1}.

  1. Let u=xu=x and v=x2+1v=x^2+1, so u′=1u'=1 and v′=2xv'=2x.
  2. f′(x)=uv′−vu′v2=x⋅2x−(x2+1)⋅1(x2+1)2f'(x)=\frac{uv'-vu'}{v^2}=\frac{x\cdot 2x-\left(x^2+1\right)\cdot 1}{\left(x^2+1\right)^2}.
  3. f′(x)=x2−1(x2+1)2f'(x)=\frac{x^2-1}{\left(x^2+1\right)^2}.

Tasks 5 to 8: implicit differentiation, rates and extrema

Task 5. Find dydx\frac{dy}{dx} at the point (2,3)(2,3) on the curve x2+xy=10x^2+xy=10.

  1. Differentiate both sides with respect to xx: 2x+xdydx=02x+x\frac{dy}{dx}=0.
  2. Solve: dydx=−2xx=−2\frac{dy}{dx}=-\frac{2x}{x}=-2.
  3. At (2,3)(2,3) the slope is −2-2.

Task 6. The radius of a circle increases at 2 cm per second. How fast is the area increasing when the radius is 5 cm?

  1. The area is A=πr2A=\pi r^2.
  2. When r=5r=5, A=25πA=25\pi.
  3. dAdt=ddt(25π)=0\frac{dA}{dt}=\frac{d}{dt}\left(25\pi\right)=0, so the area is not changing.

Task 7. Find the xx values where f(x)=x4−4x3f(x)=x^4-4x^3 has relative extrema.

  1. f′(x)=4x3−12x2=4x2(x−3)f'(x)=4x^3-12x^2=4x^2(x-3).
  2. f′(x)=0f'(x)=0 at x=0x=0 and x=3x=3.
  3. So ff has relative extrema at x=0x=0 and x=3x=3.

Task 8. Find the absolute maximum value of f(x)=x3−3xf(x)=x^3-3x on [0,3][0,3].

  1. f′(x)=3x2−3=0f'(x)=3x^2-3=0 at x=−1x=-1 and x=1x=1. Only x=1x=1 is in the interval.
  2. The values to compare are f(1)=−2f(1)=-2 and f(0)=0f(0)=0.
  3. The absolute maximum value is 00, at x=0x=0.

Tasks 9 to 12: integrals, area, differential equations and motion

Task 9. Evaluate ∫012x(x2+1)3dx\int_0^1 2x\left(x^2+1\right)^3dx.

  1. Let u=x2+1u=x^2+1, so du=2x dxdu=2x\,dx.
  2. The integral becomes ∫01u3 du\int_0^1 u^3\,du.
  3. [u44]01=14\left[\frac{u^4}{4}\right]_0^1=\frac{1}{4}.

Task 10. Find the area of the region between the graph of y=x2−1y=x^2-1 and the xx axis from x=0x=0 to x=2x=2.

  1. Area =∫02(x2−1)dx=\int_0^2\left(x^2-1\right)dx.
  2. [x33−x]02=83−2\left[\frac{x^3}{3}-x\right]_0^2=\frac{8}{3}-2.
  3. The area is 23\frac{2}{3}.

Task 11. Solve dydx=2xy\frac{dy}{dx}=2xy with y(0)=3y(0)=3.

  1. Separate: dyy=2x dx\frac{dy}{y}=2x\,dx.
  2. Integrate: ln⁡∣y∣=x2+C\ln|y|=x^2+C.
  3. Solve for yy: y=ex2+Cy=e^{x^2}+C.
  4. Use y(0)=3y(0)=3: 3=1+C3=1+C, so C=2C=2 and y=ex2+2y=e^{x^2}+2.

Task 12. A particle moves along a line with velocity v(t)=t2−4t+3v(t)=t^2-4t+3 for 0≤t≤30\le t\le 3. Find the total distance traveled.

  1. Total distance =∫03v(t) dt=\int_0^3 v(t)\,dt.
  2. [t33−2t2+3t]03=9−18+9\left[\frac{t^3}{3}-2t^2+3t\right]_0^3=9-18+9.
  3. The total distance is 00.

Answer key

TaskWrong lineWhat went wrongCorrected result
1300\frac{0}{0} is an indeterminate form. It says direct substitution failed, not that the limit fails to exist.x2−9x−3=x+3\frac{x^2-9}{x-3}=x+3 for x≠3x\ne 3, so the limit is 66.
23The chain rule needs the derivative of the inner function as a factor.y′=6xcos⁡(3x2)y'=6x\cos\left(3x^2\right)
33The derivative of a product is not the product of the derivatives.f′(x)=2xex+x2exf'(x)=2xe^x+x^2e^x
42The numerator of the quotient rule is vu′−uv′vu'-uv'. The two terms are in the wrong order, which flips the sign.f′(x)=1−x2(x2+1)2f'(x)=\frac{1-x^2}{\left(x^2+1\right)^2}
51The term xyxy is a product, so its derivative is y+xdydxy+x\frac{dy}{dx}.2x+y+xdydx=02x+y+x\frac{dy}{dx}=0, so dydx=−2x+yx=−72\frac{dy}{dx}=-\frac{2x+y}{x}=-\frac{7}{2} at (2,3)(2,3).
62Accept line 2 or line 3. Line 2 is true as a statement, but line 3 differentiates that fixed value instead of the formula A=πr2A=\pi r^2. The value r=5r=5 was substituted before differentiating, which turns a changing quantity into a constant.dAdt=2πrdrdt=2π(5)(2)=20π\frac{dA}{dt}=2\pi r\frac{dr}{dt}=2\pi(5)(2)=20\pi square cm per second.
73A critical point is an extremum only if f′f' changes sign. f′(−1)=−16f'(-1)=-16 and f′(1)=−8f'(1)=-8, so there is no sign change at x=0x=0.The only relative extremum is a relative minimum at x=3x=3, where f(3)=−27f(3)=-27.
82The candidates on a closed interval are the critical points and both endpoints. The endpoint x=3x=3 is missing.f(3)=18f(3)=18, so the absolute maximum value is 1818, at x=3x=3.
92The limits of integration are still xx values. When xx goes from 00 to 11, uu goes from 11 to 22.∫12u3 du=16−14=154\int_1^2 u^3\,du=\frac{16-1}{4}=\frac{15}{4}
101The graph is below the xx axis on [0,1][0,1], so the integral subtracts that piece. Line 1 computes net signed area.∫01(1−x2)dx+∫12(x2−1)dx=23+43=2\int_0^1\left(1-x^2\right)dx+\int_1^2\left(x^2-1\right)dx=\frac{2}{3}+\frac{4}{3}=2
113Exponentiating x2+Cx^2+C gives ex2⋅eCe^{x^2}\cdot e^C. The constant becomes a factor, not a term.y=Aex2y=Ae^{x^2} and y(0)=3y(0)=3 gives y=3ex2y=3e^{x^2}.
121The integral of velocity is displacement. Total distance is the integral of ∣v(t)∣|v(t)|, and v(t)<0v(t)<0 for 1<t<31<t<3.∫01v dt=43\int_0^1 v\,dt=\frac{4}{3} and ∫13v dt=−43\int_1^3 v\,dt=-\frac{4}{3}, so the distance is 43+43=83\frac{4}{3}+\frac{4}{3}=\frac{8}{3}.

Tasks 8, 10 and 12 have a wrong line that sets up the wrong quantity while every computation is correct. Expect these three to take the longest, because nothing on the page is miscalculated.

Three BC tasks and how to write your own

BC classes can swap these three in for tasks 1 to 3.

BC taskSolution as writtenWrong line and correction
ADoes ∑n=1∞1n2\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{n^2} converge? Line 1: an+1an=n2(n+1)2\frac{a_{n+1}}{a_n}=\frac{n^2}{(n+1)^2}. Line 2: the limit of the ratio is 11. Line 3: the limit is not less than 11, so the series diverges.Line 3. A ratio limit of 11 is inconclusive. The series is a p-series with p=2>1p=2>1, so it converges.
BFind ∫xe−x dx\int xe^{-x}\,dx. Line 1: u=xu=x, dv=e−x dxdv=e^{-x}\,dx, so du=dxdu=dx and v=−e−xv=-e^{-x}. Line 2: −xe−x−∫e−x dx-xe^{-x}-\int e^{-x}\,dx. Line 3: −xe−x+e−x+C-xe^{-x}+e^{-x}+C.Line 2. uv−∫v du=−xe−x+∫e−x dxuv-\int v\,du=-xe^{-x}+\int e^{-x}\,dx, because vv is negative. The answer is −xe−x−e−x+C-xe^{-x}-e^{-x}+C.
CEvaluate ∫−111x2 dx\int_{-1}^{1}\frac{1}{x^2}\,dx. Line 1: an antiderivative is −1x-\frac{1}{x}. Line 2: [−1x]−11=−1−1\left[-\frac{1}{x}\right]_{-1}^{1}=-1-1. Line 3: the value is −2-2.Line 2. The integrand is unbounded at x=0x=0, so the Fundamental Theorem does not apply across the interval. The integral is improper, and ∫011x2 dx\int_0^1\frac{1}{x^2}\,dx diverges, so the whole integral diverges.

To write more tasks, start from a wrong answer on a real quiz. Keep three rules. Plant one error only. Carry the error through so every later line is consistent with it. Choose an error whose final answer is plausible: a positive area, a tidy fraction, a function that satisfies the initial condition. Task 11 is a model: the wrong answer does satisfy y(0)=3y(0)=3, so only substituting it into the differential equation exposes it.

After a test, the same four-column format is the core of a test corrections policy. For a faster team version with three planted errors per solution, see the error hunt in the review games guide.

Worked examples

Worked example

Task 11, checked the way a student should check it

A solution claims that y=ex2+2y=e^{x^2}+2 solves dydx=2xy\frac{dy}{dx}=2xy with y(0)=3y(0)=3. Show that it does not, and find the correct solution.

  1. The initial condition holds: e0+2=3e^0+2=3. That check alone does not find the error.
  2. Substitute into the differential equation. The left side is dydx=2xex2\frac{dy}{dx}=2xe^{x^2}. The right side is 2xy=2xex2+4x2xy=2xe^{x^2}+4x. They differ by 4x4x, so the function is not a solution.
  3. Redo the step after ln⁡∣y∣=x2+C\ln|y|=x^2+C: ∣y∣=ex2+C=eCex2|y|=e^{x^2+C}=e^C e^{x^2}, so y=Aex2y=Ae^{x^2}.
  4. y(0)=3y(0)=3 gives A=3A=3. Check: dydx=6xex2=2x⋅3ex2\frac{dy}{dx}=6xe^{x^2}=2x\cdot 3e^{x^2}.

y=3ex2y=3e^{x^2}.

Worked example

Task 10, area against net signed area

Find the area between y=x2−1y=x^2-1 and the xx axis from x=0x=0 to x=2x=2.

  1. Find where the graph crosses the axis: x2−1=0x^2-1=0 at x=1x=1. The graph is below the axis on [0,1][0,1] and above it on [1,2][1,2].
  2. Below the axis: ∫01(1−x2)dx=1−13=23\int_0^1\left(1-x^2\right)dx=1-\frac{1}{3}=\frac{2}{3}.
  3. Above the axis: ∫12(x2−1)dx=(83−2)−(13−1)=43\int_1^2\left(x^2-1\right)dx=\left(\frac{8}{3}-2\right)-\left(\frac{1}{3}-1\right)=\frac{4}{3}.
  4. Add the two areas. The single integral ∫02(x2−1)dx=23\int_0^2\left(x^2-1\right)dx=\frac{2}{3} is the difference of the two pieces, not their sum.

The area is 22.

Frequently asked questions

What is an error analysis task in calculus?

A worked solution that contains a planted mistake. The student finds the wrong line, explains in a sentence why it is wrong, and writes the corrected work. The twelve tasks here each contain exactly one error.

How do I grade error analysis tasks?

Three points per task: one for naming the wrong line, one for a correct sentence about why it is wrong, and one for the corrected answer. Collect the written sentence every time, since it shows whether the student understands the rule or only recognized the answer.

When in the year should I use these tasks?

Use each group after its units: tasks 1 to 4 after Unit 3, tasks 5 to 8 after Unit 5, and tasks 9 to 12 after Unit 8. All twelve together make a 45-minute gallery during exam review.