AP Calculus AB and BC

AP Calculus Test Corrections Policy and Reflection Form

A complete test corrections routine: policy wording for the syllabus, a day-by-day schedule, a six-field student reflection form with four error-type codes, and four filled-in example entries with correct mathematics. Tables compare three ways to award credit and list fixes for copying and thin explanations.

The policy, ready to paste into a syllabus

The policy below is written to students. It fits on a half page, and every term in it is defined in the sections that follow.

  • After every unit test you may correct any question you missed. Corrections are optional and are due three school days after the test is returned.
  • Each correction is one entry on the reflection form: the original question, your original answer, the type of error, one sentence on why it was wrong, the full corrected work, and a twin problem that you write and solve.
  • A complete entry earns back half of the points you lost on that question. An entry with a missing field earns nothing.
  • Corrections are done by hand. You may use your notes, the textbook and classmates, and you may ask me questions. You may not copy another student's entry.
  • I may ask you to explain any entry aloud. If you cannot, that entry earns nothing.

Materials: the marked test, one copy of the reflection form per missed question or a notebook page ruled the same way, and a different color of pen. Time: 20 minutes of class on the day the test comes back, and the rest at home.

Running corrections, day by day

WhenWhat the teacher doesWhat students do
Before returning testsMark each wrong question with a circle around its number and the points lost. Do not write the correct answer or the fix on the paper.Nothing yet.
Day the test is returned, 20 minutesPost the final answers only, with no work. Show one model entry from the fourth section. Circulate and answer questions with questions.Sort every missed question by error type before fixing anything, then start the entry for the question that lost the most points.
Next two daysHold one office-hours session. Keep the answer key with work out of circulation.Finish entries at home. Write and solve a twin problem for each.
Due dateCollect the forms stapled to the test. Check each entry against the six fields, spot-check two twin problems per student, and choose three students for a one-minute oral check.Hand in the forms. Be ready to explain any entry.
Within a weekEnter the recovered points. Tally error types for the class and use the most common one to plan a warm-up.Record their own error-type tally on the inside cover of the notebook.

Returning the test without the fixes written on it is the step that makes the rest work. A student who is handed the corrected solution copies it. A student who is told only that question 7 is wrong has to find the error, and finding it is the work that the half credit pays for.

The student reflection form

One form per missed question. The form has six fields, and all six must be filled in for the entry to count.

FieldWhat the student writes
1. QuestionThe question number and the question, copied in full.
2. My original answerWhat was written on the test, including the wrong work, not only the final line.
3. Error typeOne of the four codes below.
4. Why it was wrongOne or two full sentences that name the rule, definition or condition that was broken. Not acceptable: I made a mistake, or I forgot.
5. Corrected workThe complete solution, written as it should have appeared on the test.
6. Twin problemA new problem of the same kind with different numbers or a different function, written by the student and solved in full.
CodeError typeTypical examples in calculus
CConceptUsed the wrong idea: read a graph of f′f' as a graph of ff, treated an average rate as an instantaneous rate, concluded a limit does not exist from 00\frac{0}{0}.
PProcedureChose the right idea and carried it out wrong: left out the inner derivative in the chain rule, did not change the limits in a substitution, misapplied the product rule.
WWritten communicationThe mathematics was right and the writing lost the points: a conclusion with no reason, a theorem used without its conditions, missing units, a dropped limit symbol or differential.
AAccuracyArithmetic, a sign, a copying error, or a calculator in the wrong mode.

Students often code an error as accuracy when it is not. When an entry is coded A, ask whether the same slip would have happened on an easier problem of the same kind. If not, the error is usually P or C.

Four example entries

Show students at least one of these before their first set of corrections. Each one is a different error type.

Example 1, a procedure error.

FieldEntry
1. QuestionDifferentiate f(x)=x2ln⁡xf(x)=x^2\ln x.
2. My original answerf′(x)=2x⋅1x=2f'(x)=2x\cdot\frac{1}{x}=2
3. Error typeP
4. Why it was wrongI multiplied the derivatives of the two factors. The derivative of a product is the first derivative times the second function plus the first function times the second derivative.
5. Corrected workf′(x)=2xln⁡x+x2⋅1x=2xln⁡x+xf'(x)=2x\ln x+x^2\cdot\frac{1}{x}=2x\ln x+x
6. Twin problemDifferentiate g(x)=x3exg(x)=x^3e^x. g′(x)=3x2ex+x3exg'(x)=3x^2e^x+x^3e^x.

Example 2, a concept error.

FieldEntry
1. QuestionFind lim⁡x→∞2x2+1x2−3x\lim_{x\to\infty}\frac{2x^2+1}{x^2-3x}.
2. My original answerThe top and the bottom both go to infinity, so the limit is ∞\infty.
3. Error typeC
4. Why it was wrongThe form ∞∞\frac{\infty}{\infty} is indeterminate. It does not tell me the limit. I have to compare how fast the numerator and denominator grow.
5. Corrected workDivide the numerator and denominator by x2x^2: 2+1x21−3x→2+01−0=2\frac{2+\frac{1}{x^2}}{1-\frac{3}{x}}\to\frac{2+0}{1-0}=2.
6. Twin problemFind lim⁡x→∞5x3−x2x3+4\lim_{x\to\infty}\frac{5x^3-x}{2x^3+4}. Divide by x3x^3: 5−1x22+4x3→52\frac{5-\frac{1}{x^2}}{2+\frac{4}{x^3}}\to\frac{5}{2}.

Example 3, a written communication error.

FieldEntry
1. Questionf′(x)=x2−2x−3f'(x)=x^2-2x-3. Show that ff has a relative minimum at x=3x=3.
2. My original answerff has a relative minimum at x=3x=3 because f′(3)=0f'(3)=0.
3. Error typeW
4. Why it was wrongf′(3)=0f'(3)=0 only shows that x=3x=3 is a critical point. A relative minimum needs f′f' to change from negative to positive there, and I did not show that.
5. Corrected workf′(x)=(x−3)(x+1)f'(x)=(x-3)(x+1). For −1<x<3-1<x<3, f′(x)<0f'(x)<0. For x>3x>3, f′(x)>0f'(x)>0. Since f′f' changes from negative to positive at x=3x=3, ff has a relative minimum there.
6. Twin problemg′(x)=(x−1)(x+4)g'(x)=(x-1)(x+4). Classify x=−4x=-4. For x<−4x<-4, g′(x)>0g'(x)>0. For −4<x<1-4<x<1, g′(x)<0g'(x)<0. g′g' changes from positive to negative at x=−4x=-4, so gg has a relative maximum there.

Example 4, an accuracy error.

FieldEntry
1. QuestionEvaluate ∫13(2x−4) dx\int_1^3(2x-4)\,dx.
2. My original answer[x2−4x]13=(9−12)−(1−4)=−3−3=−6\left[x^2-4x\right]_1^3=(9-12)-(1-4)=-3-3=-6
3. Error typeA
4. Why it was wrongThe antiderivative and both substitutions were right. I subtracted −3-3 as if it were 33. From now on I will keep the second value in parentheses until the last step.
5. Corrected work(9−12)−(1−4)=(−3)−(−3)=0(9-12)-(1-4)=(-3)-(-3)=0
6. Twin problemEvaluate ∫03(2x−1) dx\int_0^3(2x-1)\,dx. [x2−x]03=(9−3)−(0)=6\left[x^2-x\right]_0^3=(9-3)-(0)=6.

How much credit, and three ways to give it

The policy above returns half of the lost points. That is one of three common arrangements, and each has a cost.

ArrangementHow it worksWhat it costs
Half of lost pointsEach complete entry earns back half the points lost on that question.Grades rise for every student who does the work, so the test score no longer shows first-attempt performance by itself. Record both scores.
Ticket to a retakeComplete corrections on every missed question are required before a student may take a shorter second version of the test. The retake score replaces or is averaged with the original.You need a second version of each test and time to give it.
Homework credit onlyCorrections are graded as an assignment and the test score does not change.Expect fewer students to do them, since the test score cannot improve.

Whichever arrangement you choose, keep the first-attempt score in your records next to the adjusted one. The first-attempt scores are what tell you how the class is likely to perform on an exam that allows no corrections.

A cap that keeps the test meaningful

Under the half-credit arrangement a student who scored 60 percent can reach 80 percent at most, and a student who scored 90 can reach 95. State this arithmetic in the syllabus so that no one expects corrections to turn a failing test into a perfect one.

Problems to head off

ProblemWhat to do
Entries copied from a classmateRequire the twin problem to be the student's own. Two students with the same twin problem both lose the entry. Use the one-minute oral check on three students each time.
Field 4 says only: careless mistakeReturn the entry unscored. A sentence that does not name a rule, definition or condition is not an explanation.
Twin problems that are trivialRequire the twin to be at least as hard as the original: the same number of steps and no simpler function.
Corrections take over your eveningsScore entries as complete or not complete. Read fields 3 and 4 and check the final line of fields 5 and 6. Do not regrade the mathematics line by line.
Strong students never do correctionsAsk students with one or two missed questions to write a twin problem with a planted error for the class, in the format of the error analysis tasks.

The class tally of error types is the output to plan from. A class that loses most of its points to written communication needs sentence practice, which the explain items in the warm-ups by unit provide. A class that loses them to procedure errors on one skill needs that skill retaught, not more tests. During exam review, the same form is used on the corrections days of the exam review plan.

Worked examples

Worked example

Checking the twin problem in example 2

Find lim⁡x→∞5x3−x2x3+4\lim_{x\to\infty}\frac{5x^3-x}{2x^3+4}.

  1. Both the numerator and the denominator grow without bound, so the form is indeterminate and the expression has to be rewritten.
  2. Divide every term by x3x^3, the highest power in the denominator: 5−1x22+4x3\frac{5-\frac{1}{x^2}}{2+\frac{4}{x^3}}.
  3. As x→∞x\to\infty, 1x2→0\frac{1}{x^2}\to 0 and 4x3→0\frac{4}{x^3}\to 0.

The limit is 52\frac{5}{2}.

Worked example

The arithmetic of half credit

A test is worth 50 points. A student scores 32 and submits complete corrections for questions that lost 12 of the 18 missing points. What is the adjusted score, and what is the highest score this student could have reached?

  1. Each complete entry earns back half of the points lost on its question, so the student recovers 12⋅12=6\frac{1}{2}\cdot 12=6 points.
  2. The adjusted score is 32+6=3832+6=38 out of 5050, which is 7676 percent. The first-attempt score was 6464 percent.
  3. With complete corrections on every missed question the student would recover 12⋅18=9\frac{1}{2}\cdot 18=9 points, for 4141 out of 5050.

The adjusted score is 38 out of 50. The most this student could reach is 41 out of 50, or 82 percent.

Frequently asked questions

How much credit should test corrections earn in AP Calculus?

A common arrangement returns half of the points lost on each question that is fully corrected. A student who scored 60 percent can then reach at most 80 percent. Keep the first-attempt score on record beside the adjusted one.

What should a test correction include?

Six things: the original question, the original wrong answer, the type of error, one or two sentences on why it was wrong, the full corrected work, and a twin problem the student writes and solves.

How do I stop students from copying corrections?

Return tests without the fixes written on them, require a twin problem each student writes, and ask three students each time to explain one entry aloud for a minute. An entry the student cannot explain earns nothing.