AP Calculus AB and BC

After the AP Calculus Exam: Lessons and Projects

Eight activities for the weeks after the exam, four of them written out in full: a Newton's method lesson with four problems and answers, integration by parts and the shell method for classes that have not seen them, and a spreadsheet epidemic model with checkpoint values. A three-week calendar puts them in order.

Eight options and how long each takes

The weeks after the exam work best with short units that end in something a student hands in. The table lists eight options. The first four are written out in full below, with every problem and answer, so they can be taught from this page.

OptionDaysMaterialsWhat students hand in
Newton's method lesson1 to 2Scientific or graphing calculatorA table of iterations for three equations and one case where the method fails
Integration by parts for AB classes1NoneFour integrals with work, the three indefinite ones checked by differentiating
Shell method for AB or BC classes1NoneTwo volumes, one confirmed with washers
Epidemic model in a spreadsheet3 to 4A spreadsheet per pairA graph of the three curves and a one-page answer to four questions
Gabriel's horn discussion1NoneA paragraph explaining how a solid can have finite volume and infinite surface area
Teach-back videos4 to 5A phone per groupA five-minute lesson on one course topic for next year's class
Letter to next year's students1PaperA one-page letter with three specific pieces of advice
Projects from the project list5 to 10VariesSee the project ideas guide

None of the first three lessons is graded as a test. Collect the work, check it against the keys below, and return it the next day.

Lesson: Newton's method, with problems and key

Newton's method is not in the AP Calculus Course and Exam Description, which makes it a fair topic for after the exam. It needs only the tangent line, which students have used since Topic 2.2, Defining the Derivative of a Function and Using Derivative Notation. Start from a guess x0x_0, follow the tangent line to the xx axis, and repeat.

xn+1=xn−f(xn)f′(xn)x_{n+1}=x_n-\frac{f(x_n)}{f'(x_n)}

Derive the formula with the class in ten minutes. The tangent line at xnx_n is y=f(xn)+f′(xn)(x−xn)y=f(x_n)+f'(x_n)(x-x_n). Set y=0y=0 and solve for xx. Then hand out the four problems.

No.ProblemKey
1Approximate 2\sqrt{2} by solving x2−2=0x^2-2=0 with x0=1x_0=1. Find x1x_1, x2x_2 and x3x_3.x1=32x_1=\frac{3}{2}, x2=1712≈1.416667x_2=\frac{17}{12}\approx 1.416667, x3=577408≈1.414216x_3=\frac{577}{408}\approx 1.414216. The true value is 1.4142141.414214 to six places.
2Solve x3−2x−5=0x^3-2x-5=0 with x0=2x_0=2. Find x1x_1 and x2x_2.x1=2−−110=2.1x_1=2-\frac{-1}{10}=2.1 and x2=2.1−0.06111.23≈2.094568x_2=2.1-\frac{0.061}{11.23}\approx 2.094568. The root is 2.0945512.094551 to six places.
3Solve cos⁡x=x\cos x=x with x0=1x_0=1, in radians. Use f(x)=cos⁡x−xf(x)=\cos x-x. Find x1x_1 and x2x_2.x1≈0.750364x_1\approx 0.750364 and x2≈0.739113x_2\approx 0.739113. The root is 0.7390850.739085 to six places.
4Apply the method to f(x)=x1/3f(x)=x^{1/3} with x0=1x_0=1. Find x1x_1, x2x_2 and x3x_3. What goes wrong?f(x)f′(x)=3x\frac{f(x)}{f'(x)}=3x, so xn+1=−2xnx_{n+1}=-2x_n. The iterates are −2-2, 44, −8-8. They move away from the root at 00 because the tangent line is vertical there.

Close by asking how many correct digits each step gained in problem 1: one, then three, then six. Students can see the number of correct digits roughly doubling without any proof.

Two techniques AB students have not seen

Integration by parts is Topic 6.11, Integrating Using Integration by Parts, a BC-only topic, so AB classes meet it here for the first time. Derive it from the product rule in five minutes: integrate both sides of (uv)′=u′v+uv′(uv)'=u'v+uv'.

∫u dv=uv−∫v du\int u\,dv=uv-\int v\,du
No.IntegralChoice of uu and dvdvAnswer
1∫xex dx\int xe^x\,dxu=xu=x, dv=ex dxdv=e^x\,dxxex−ex+Cxe^x-e^x+C
2∫xcos⁡x dx\int x\cos x\,dxu=xu=x, dv=cos⁡x dxdv=\cos x\,dxxsin⁡x+cos⁡x+Cx\sin x+\cos x+C
3∫ln⁡x dx\int\ln x\,dxu=ln⁡xu=\ln x, dv=dxdv=dxxln⁡x−x+Cx\ln x-x+C
4∫01xe2x dx\int_0^1 xe^{2x}\,dxu=xu=x, dv=e2x dxdv=e^{2x}\,dxe2+14\frac{e^2+1}{4}

Students check each indefinite answer by differentiating it, which turns the lesson into product rule review as well.

The shell method is not in the Course and Exam Description for either course. It answers a question students have already met: what to do when revolving about the yy axis and solving for xx is awkward. A thin vertical strip at position xx with height h(x)h(x) sweeps out a cylindrical shell.

V=2π∫abx h(x) dxV=2\pi\int_a^b x\,h(x)\,dx
No.Region, revolved about the yy axisSetupVolume
1Under y=2x−x2y=2x-x^2 from x=0x=0 to x=2x=22π∫02x(2x−x2)dx2\pi\int_0^2 x\left(2x-x^2\right)dx8π3\frac{8\pi}{3}
2Under y=xy=\sqrt{x} from x=0x=0 to x=4x=42π∫04xx dx2\pi\int_0^4 x\sqrt{x}\,dx128π5\frac{128\pi}{5}

Have students confirm problem 2 with washers in yy: the outer radius is 44 and the inner radius is x=y2x=y^2, so V=π∫02(16−y4)dy=128π5V=\pi\int_0^2\left(16-y^4\right)dy=\frac{128\pi}{5}. Then ask them to try problem 1 with washers. Solving y=2x−x2y=2x-x^2 for xx gives two branches, which is the reason shells exist. The disk, washer and shell guide compares the three methods.

Project: an epidemic in a spreadsheet

This project applies Euler's method to a system of three differential equations. AB students have not seen Euler's method, so teach one step by hand first. A population of 1000 is split into susceptible SS, infected II and recovered RR. Each day, new infections are proportional to the product SISI and a fixed fraction of infected people recover.

dSdt=−0.0003 SIdIdt=0.0003 SI−0.1 IdRdt=0.1 I\frac{dS}{dt}=-0.0003\,SI \qquad \frac{dI}{dt}=0.0003\,SI-0.1\,I \qquad \frac{dR}{dt}=0.1\,I

Start with S=990S=990, I=10I=10, R=0R=0 and use a step of one day. Each row of the spreadsheet is the previous row plus one day of change. Students compute the first two rows by hand before writing formulas.

DaySSIIRR
0990100
1987.0311.971.00
2983.4914.322.20
10917.9257.0025.08
20636.22219.05144.73
30261.53310.37428.09
40114.74193.73691.53

The rows for days 10 through 40 are checkpoints. A pair whose spreadsheet does not match them has a formula error, often a formula that reads the wrong row.

  1. On which day does II peak, and how many people are infected then? Key: day 28, about 316.
  2. What is SS when II peaks, and why? Key: about 319. II grows only while 0.0003 S>0.10.0003\,S>0.1, which is S>333.3S>333.3. SS is about 352 on day 27 and about 319 on day 28, so day 28 is the last day II rises.
  3. Check that S+I+R=1000S+I+R=1000 in every row and explain why from the three equations. Key: the three derivatives add to zero.
  4. Change the recovery fraction from 0.10.1 to 0.20.2 and describe what happens to the peak. Key: the peak is much lower, about 72 infected on day 34, because II now stops growing once SS falls below 666.7666.7.

Grade the one-page write-up on four things: the spreadsheet matches the checkpoints, the graph has labeled axes and three labeled curves, each of the four answers gives a number and a reason, and the explanation of the peak uses the sign of a derivative.

Projects that need no new mathematics

Teach-back videos: groups of three pick one topic from the course that they found hard, and record a five-minute lesson for next year's students. Require one worked example, one common mistake with its correction, and one check for the viewer to try. Play the best ones next year on the day that topic is introduced.

Letter to next year's students: one page, written in class, with three specific pieces of advice. Ban general advice such as study hard. A usable letter names a unit, a habit and a week, for example what the writer wishes they had done during related rates. Hand the letters out on the first day of AP Calculus next fall.

Gabriel's horn: revolve y=1xy=\frac{1}{x} for x≥1x\ge 1 about the xx axis. BC students can compute the volume as an improper integral, π∫1∞1x2 dx=π\pi\int_1^\infty\frac{1}{x^2}\,dx=\pi. AB students can compute π∫1b1x2 dx=π(1−1b)\pi\int_1^b\frac{1}{x^2}\,dx=\pi\left(1-\frac{1}{b}\right) and let bb grow. The surface area is at least 2π∫1b1x dx=2πln⁡b2\pi\int_1^b\frac{1}{x}\,dx=2\pi\ln b, which grows without bound. The discussion question is how a horn that holds a finite amount of paint cannot be painted, and a good answer notices that a coat of paint with any fixed thickness stops fitting inside the narrowing horn.

A sample three-week calendar

DaysAB classBC class
1Letter to next year's students, then choose teach-back topicsLetter to next year's students, then choose teach-back topics
2 to 3Newton's method lesson and problemsNewton's method lesson and problems
4Integration by partsShell method
5Shell methodGabriel's horn with improper integrals
6 to 9Epidemic model, with one day on Euler's method by handEpidemic model, then vary both parameters
10 to 14Teach-back videos: plan, record, edit, showTeach-back videos: plan, record, edit, show
15Gabriel's horn discussion and course reflectionCourse reflection

If seniors leave early, run days 1 through 9 with the whole class and let the remaining students do the videos. If the exam is early in the testing window and four or more weeks remain, add one of the longer projects from the project ideas guide after day 9.

Worked examples

Worked example

Newton's method, problem 2 in full

Use Newton's method with x0=2x_0=2 to find x1x_1 and x2x_2 for f(x)=x3−2x−5f(x)=x^3-2x-5.

  1. f′(x)=3x2−2f'(x)=3x^2-2.
  2. f(2)=8−4−5=−1f(2)=8-4-5=-1 and f′(2)=10f'(2)=10, so x1=2−−110=2.1x_1=2-\frac{-1}{10}=2.1.
  3. f(2.1)=9.261−4.2−5=0.061f(2.1)=9.261-4.2-5=0.061 and f′(2.1)=13.23−2=11.23f'(2.1)=13.23-2=11.23.
  4. x2=2.1−0.06111.23≈2.1−0.005432=2.094568x_2=2.1-\frac{0.061}{11.23}\approx 2.1-0.005432=2.094568.

x1=2.1x_1=2.1 and x2≈2.094568x_2\approx 2.094568.

Worked example

The first two rows of the epidemic spreadsheet

With S=990S=990, I=10I=10, R=0R=0 on day 0, an infection constant of 0.00030.0003, a recovery fraction of 0.10.1 and a step of one day, find the values on day 1 and day 2.

  1. Day 0 to day 1: new infections are 0.0003⋅990⋅10=2.970.0003\cdot 990\cdot 10=2.97 and recoveries are 0.1⋅10=10.1\cdot 10=1.
  2. So S=990−2.97=987.03S=990-2.97=987.03, I=10+2.97−1=11.97I=10+2.97-1=11.97 and R=1R=1.
  3. Day 1 to day 2: new infections are 0.0003⋅987.03⋅11.97≈3.5440.0003\cdot 987.03\cdot 11.97\approx 3.544 and recoveries are 1.1971.197.
  4. So S≈983.49S\approx 983.49, I≈11.97+3.544−1.197=14.32I\approx 11.97+3.544-1.197=14.32 and R≈2.20R\approx 2.20.

Day 1: S=987.03S=987.03, I=11.97I=11.97, R=1R=1. Day 2: S≈983.49S\approx 983.49, I≈14.32I\approx 14.32, R≈2.20R\approx 2.20.

Frequently asked questions

What should I teach after the AP Calculus exam?

Short topics that are outside the exam and end in something students hand in. Newton's method, the shell method and, for AB classes, integration by parts each fit in one or two days. A spreadsheet epidemic model and teach-back videos fill a week each.

How do I keep seniors working after the AP exam?

Use tasks with a product and an audience. The teach-back videos and the letters are shown to next year's class, and the spreadsheet has checkpoints a pair either matches or does not, which gives each day a clear finish.

Is Newton's method on the AP Calculus exam?

No. It is not a topic in the current Course and Exam Description for AB or BC. It uses only the tangent line, so students can learn it in one period after the exam.