AP Calculus AB and BC

Volumes of Revolution Classroom Activity: Measure a Vase

Students measure the circumference of a vase or bottle every 2 cm, turn each measurement into a disk, and add the disk volumes. They then fit a radius function and integrate pi times radius squared, and check both answers by filling the object with water. A sample data set with a full key is included.

Objective and materials

Students estimate the volume of a real object with circular cross-sections in two ways: a finite sum of disks from measurements, and a definite integral of a fitted radius function. They then compare both with a direct measurement. The activity serves CED Topic 8.9, Volume with Disc Method: Revolving Around the x- or y-Axis.

  • One vase, bottle or jar per group, with circular cross-sections and a flat base
  • String or a strip of paper, and a ruler in centimeters
  • Masking tape and a fine marker
  • A graphing calculator or spreadsheet with regression
  • A measuring cup or graduated cylinder in milliliters, and water, for the check

Thin-walled plastic bottles give the closest agreement, because the outside radius is nearly the inside radius. Students need the area of a circle, Riemann or trapezoidal sums, and the definite integral. The disk method can be introduced by this lab.

A 45-minute sequence

MinutesTeacher moveStudent evidence
0 to 5Hold up an object and ask for volume estimates in milliliters. Record the range of guesses.A written guess.
5 to 17Groups mark heights and measure circumferences.A table of heights, circumferences and radii.
17 to 25Groups compute cross-section areas and a trapezoidal sum.A volume estimate from slices.
25 to 35Groups fit a radius function and set up and evaluate the integral.A regression equation, an integral and its value.
35 to 41Groups fill the object with water to the top mark and measure the water.A measured volume and two percent differences.
41 to 45Compare methods across groups. Exit check.A written exit check.

Student steps

  1. Run a strip of masking tape up the side of the object. Mark h=0h=0 at the inside bottom level and then every 2 cm, measured vertically, up to the fill line you choose.
  2. At each mark, wrap the string once around the object, keeping it level. Measure the length of string to get the circumference CC.
  3. Convert each circumference to a radius with r=C2πr=\frac{C}{2\pi}, and compute the cross-section area A=πr2A=\pi r^2.
  4. Estimate the volume with a trapezoidal sum of the areas: for each 2 cm slab, average the areas at its bottom and top and multiply by 22.
  5. Enter the pairs (h,r)(h,r) into a calculator, fit a function r(h)r(h) by regression, and evaluate V=π∫0H[r(h)]2 dhV=\pi\int_0^H [r(h)]^2\,dh, where HH is the top mark.
  6. Fill the object with water to the top mark, pour the water into the measuring cup and record the volume. One cubic centimeter is one milliliter.
  7. Compute the percent difference between each estimate and the measured volume.

Vertical height, not distance along the surface

The marks must be 2 cm apart vertically. On a curved side, tape laid along the surface travels farther than the height it gains. Stand a ruler upright beside the object and transfer the heights across.

Why the integral has this form

A thin horizontal slice at height hh is close to a disk with radius r(h)r(h) and thickness Δh\Delta h, so its volume is close to π[r(h)]2 Δh\pi[r(h)]^2\,\Delta h. Adding the slices gives a Riemann sum, and its limit as the slices get thinner is the integral.

V=lim⁡n→∞∑i=1nπ [r(hi)]2 Δh=π∫0H[r(h)]2 dhV=\lim_{n\to\infty}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\pi\,[r(h_i)]^2\,\Delta h=\pi\int_0^H [r(h)]^2\,dh

This is the disk method with the axis of the object as the axis of revolution: the object is the solid made by revolving its profile curve r(h)r(h) around that axis.

Sample data set and answer key

Use this data set to practice the method or to give absent students the full calculation. It was generated from a known profile so that every step can be checked exactly. Real measurements will not fit a quadratic this well. Radii are rounded to the nearest 0.10.1 cm, and the areas use the rounded radii.

Height hh (cm)Circumference CC (cm)Radius rr (cm)Area πr2\pi r^2 (sq cm)
0018.818.83.03.028.2728.27
2223.923.93.83.845.3645.36
4426.426.44.24.255.4255.42
6626.426.44.24.255.4255.42
8823.923.93.83.845.3645.36
101018.818.83.03.028.2728.27
121211.311.31.81.810.1810.18

Sums of slices with Δh=2\Delta h=2, using the areas in the last column:

MethodCalculationVolume (cubic cm)
Left sum2⋅(28.27+45.36+55.42+55.42+45.36+28.27)2\cdot(28.27+45.36+55.42+55.42+45.36+28.27)516.2516.2
Right sum2⋅(45.36+55.42+55.42+45.36+28.27+10.18)2\cdot(45.36+55.42+55.42+45.36+28.27+10.18)480.0480.0
Trapezoidal sumAverage of the left and right sums498.1498.1

Quadratic regression on the pairs (h,r)(h,r) returns r(h)=3+0.5h−0.05h2r(h)=3+0.5h-0.05h^2, which passes through all seven points. Square it and integrate.

[r(h)]2=9+3h−0.05h2−0.05h3+0.0025h4[r(h)]^2=9+3h-0.05h^2-0.05h^3+0.0025h^4
∫012[r(h)]2 dh=[9h+1.5h2−0.053h3−0.0125h4+0.0005h5]012=108+216−28.8−259.2+124.416=160.416\int_0^{12}[r(h)]^2\,dh=\left[9h+1.5h^2-\frac{0.05}{3}h^3-0.0125h^4+0.0005h^5\right]_0^{12}=108+216-28.8-259.2+124.416=160.416
V=160.416 π≈504.0 cubic cmV=160.416\,\pi\approx 504.0 \text{ cubic cm}

The trapezoidal sum is about 1.21.2 percent below the integral. The left sum is about 2.42.4 percent above it and the right sum about 4.84.8 percent below it.

What students should notice

  • The radius is squared before adding. Averaging the radii first and then computing one cylinder gives a different, incorrect volume.
  • The left and right sums differ by 2⋅(28.27−10.18)≈36.22\cdot(28.27-10.18)\approx 36.2 cubic centimeters, which is the slab thickness times the difference between the bottom and top areas. Thinner slabs shrink that gap.
  • The integral of the fitted function is only as good as the fit. A function that misses the measured radii by a few millimeters will miss the volume too.
  • Outside measurements include the wall. If the wall is 0.30.3 cm thick where the outside radius is 44 cm, the inside radius is 3.73.7 cm, and the inside area is (3.74)2≈0.86\left(\frac{3.7}{4}\right)^2\approx 0.86 of the outside area, about 14 percent less. Glass objects should be corrected for wall thickness. Thin plastic needs little correction.

Discussion questions

  1. Why does the integrand contain [r(h)]2[r(h)]^2 and not r(h)r(h)? Answer: each slice is a disk, and the area of a disk is πr2\pi r^2. Integrating r(h)r(h) alone would give the area under the profile curve, a quantity in square centimeters.
  2. How would the calculation change with marks every 1 cm? Answer: there would be twice as many slabs, each with Δh=1\Delta h=1. The sums would move closer to the integral, and the regression would have more points to fit.
  3. Which estimate should be closest to the water measurement, and why might none of them match? Answer: the integral or the trapezoidal sum, if the fit is good. Wall thickness, a string that was not level, a curved base and reading the measuring cup all add error.
  4. What if the object is narrower in the middle than at both ends? Answer: nothing in the method changes. The radius function has a minimum in the middle, and the integral still adds disks.

Exit check

A solid has circular cross-sections with radius r(h)=hr(h)=\sqrt{h} centimeters at height hh, for 0≤h≤40\le h\le 4. Write an integral for its volume and evaluate it.

Key: V=π∫04(h)2 dh=π∫04h dh=π[h22]04=8π≈25.13V=\pi\int_0^4(\sqrt{h})^2\,dh=\pi\int_0^4 h\,dh=\pi\left[\frac{h^2}{2}\right]_0^4=8\pi\approx 25.13 cubic centimeters.

Extension and follow-up

  • Better fits: try cubic or quartic regression and compare the volumes. For an object with a long straight neck, fit the body and the neck separately and add two integrals.
  • Hollow objects: for a thick-walled object, measure the wall thickness ww and compute the volume of the side wall with washers, π∫0H([r(h)]2−[r(h)−w]2)dh\pi\int_0^H\left([r(h)]^2-[r(h)-w]^2\right)dh. This connects to CED Topic 8.11, Volume with Washer Method: Revolving Around the x- or y-Axis.
  • Design task: students choose a profile function, compute the volume of the solid, and sketch the object it would make.

Students can see disks, washers and shells assembled from a region with the Solid of Revolution Builder. The disk, washer and shell guide covers the written method, and volumes with known cross sections covers solids whose slices are not circles.

Worked examples

Worked example

Trapezoidal sum for the sample data

Using the sample areas 28.2728.27, 45.3645.36, 55.4255.42, 55.4255.42, 45.3645.36, 28.2728.27 and 10.1810.18 square centimeters at heights 00 through 1212 cm in steps of 22 cm, estimate the volume with a trapezoidal sum.

  1. Each slab is 22 cm thick. Its volume is approximated by 22 times the average of the areas at its bottom and top.
  2. Adding the six slabs, each interior area is counted twice with weight 12\frac{1}{2} and each end area once with weight 12\frac{1}{2}: V≈2⋅[28.27+10.182+45.36+55.42+55.42+45.36+28.27]V\approx 2\cdot\left[\frac{28.27+10.18}{2}+45.36+55.42+55.42+45.36+28.27\right].
  3. Compute the bracket: 19.225+229.83=249.05519.225+229.83=249.055.
  4. Multiply by the slab thickness: 2⋅249.055=498.112\cdot 249.055=498.11.

About 498.1498.1 cubic centimeters, or 498.1498.1 mL.

Worked example

Volume by integrating the fitted profile

The fitted radius function is r(h)=3+0.5h−0.05h2r(h)=3+0.5h-0.05h^2 centimeters for 0≤h≤120\le h\le 12. Find the volume of the solid of revolution.

  1. Set up the disk integral: V=π∫012(3+0.5h−0.05h2)2 dhV=\pi\int_0^{12}(3+0.5h-0.05h^2)^2\,dh.
  2. Expand the square: 9+3h−0.05h2−0.05h3+0.0025h49+3h-0.05h^2-0.05h^3+0.0025h^4. The h2h^2 coefficient combines 0.250.25 from (0.5h)2(0.5h)^2 with −0.3-0.3 from 2⋅3⋅(−0.05h2)2\cdot 3\cdot(-0.05h^2).
  3. Antidifferentiate: 9h+1.5h2−0.053h3−0.0125h4+0.0005h59h+1.5h^2-\frac{0.05}{3}h^3-0.0125h^4+0.0005h^5.
  4. Evaluate at 1212: 108+216−28.8−259.2+124.416=160.416108+216-28.8-259.2+124.416=160.416. The value at 00 is 00.
  5. Multiply by π\pi: 160.416 π≈503.96160.416\,\pi\approx 503.96.

V=160.416 π≈504.0V=160.416\,\pi\approx 504.0 cubic centimeters.

Frequently asked questions

What objects work best for this volume activity?

Objects with circular cross-sections, a flat base and thin walls: plastic drink bottles, plastic vases and jars. Avoid square bottles and objects with handles.

Why measure circumference and not diameter?

A string around the object is easier to read accurately than a ruler held across a curved surface. Divide the circumference by 2π2\pi to get the radius.

What if students have not learned the disk method yet?

The lab can introduce it. Students already know the volume of a cylinder, and the slab sum leads to the integral in the same way a Riemann sum leads to area.

Can it run without water?

Yes. Use an object with a labeled capacity, or compare the slab sum with the integral and skip the direct check. The sample data set also supports a paper-only version.