AP Calculus AB and BC
Fundamental Theorem Classroom Activity: Rate to Total
Students get a graph of the rate at which water enters and leaves a tank, find the accumulated amount at each minute by area, and plot it. Measuring slopes on the new graph returns the original rate, which is the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus. The rate graph, every table value and a key are included.
Objective and materials
Students build an accumulation function from a rate graph by geometry, discover that its rate of change is the original rate, and use that to compute net change as a difference of two values. The activity serves CED Topic 6.1, Exploring Accumulations of Change, Topic 6.4, The Fundamental Theorem of Calculus and Accumulation Functions, Topic 6.5, Interpreting the Behavior of Accumulation Functions Involving Area, and Topic 6.7, The Fundamental Theorem of Calculus and Definite Integrals.
- Graph paper, two sheets per student
- A ruler and two colored pencils
- The rate graph, drawn on the board or copied onto a handout
- A calculator for the slope step
Students need areas of triangles, rectangles and trapezoids, the idea that area below the horizontal axis counts as negative, and the derivative as a slope. They do not need antiderivative rules.
The rate graph
Water flows into and out of a tank. The rate , in liters per minute, is given for minutes by straight segments joining these points in order:
| (min) | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| (L per min) |
A positive rate means water is entering. A negative rate means water is leaving. On the segment from to the rate falls by each minute and crosses zero at . Have students draw the graph on the first sheet with one grid square per minute across and per liter per minute up.
Define the accumulation function , the net amount of water, in liters, that has entered the tank by time .
A 45-minute sequence
| Minutes | Teacher move | Student evidence |
|---|---|---|
| 0 to 6 | Present the rate graph. Ask for a prediction: at what time does the tank hold the most water? | A drawn rate graph and a written prediction. |
| 6 to 18 | Students find for by adding areas, one minute at a time. | A completed accumulation table. |
| 18 to 25 | Students plot on the second sheet and join the points with a smooth curve. | A graph of the accumulation function. |
| 25 to 34 | Students estimate the slope of at each whole minute and compare with . | A slope table next to the rate values. |
| 34 to 41 | State the theorem. Students compute a net change two ways. | Two matching calculations. |
| 41 to 45 | Exit check. | A written exit check. |
Student steps
- Shade the region between the rate graph and the -axis from to and find its area. This is .
- Add the area from to to get . Continue one minute at a time through . Areas below the axis are subtracted.
- Plot the eleven points on the second sheet. Draw a smooth curve through them.
- At each from to , estimate the slope of with the points on both sides: .
- Write the slope estimates in a row under the rate values and compare.
Answer key: accumulation table
| Area added in the last minute | |||||||||||
Each one-minute area is a triangle, rectangle or trapezoid. From to , for example, the rate falls from to , so the area is . From to the region is a triangle below the axis with area , counted as .
For teachers who want the formulas: on , on , on , and on .
Answer key: slope table
| Slope estimate | |||||||||
The estimates equal the rate at . They miss at , and , the three places where the rate graph has a corner. The two-sided estimate averages the behavior one minute to each side, and at a corner the two sides follow different lines.
A narrower estimate closes the gap. At , using half a minute to each side, and , so the estimate is , closer to . The exact slope of at is : from the formulas, has slope on the left and has slope on the right.
The theorem students have found
The slope of the accumulation graph at each time equals the height of the rate graph at that time. This is the first part of the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus: if is continuous, then
So is an antiderivative of . The second part follows from the table. The net change in the amount of water between two times is a difference of two values of :
Check with and . By area: liters from to , then from to , then and , for a total of . By the table: .
Any antiderivative gives the same difference. If the tank held liters at the start, the amount in the tank is , and . The constant cancels in the subtraction.
What students should notice
- increases while is positive, on , and decreases while is negative, on .
- has its maximum, liters, at , where changes from positive to negative. At the rate only starts to fall, and water keeps entering until .
- is concave up on , where is increasing, and concave down on , where is decreasing.
- is a straight line where is constant: slope on and slope on .
- The rate graph has corners at , and , but the graph of is smooth there.
Discussion questions
- Many students predict the tank is fullest at . Why is that wrong? Answer: at the rate begins to decrease, but it is still positive until . The amount keeps growing as long as the rate is above zero.
- The rate is at the end. Does that mean the tank holds a negative amount? Answer: no. liters have entered on net. The rate describes how the amount is changing at that moment and says nothing about its size.
- Is the net amount entering from to the same as the total amount of water that moved through the pipe? Answer: no. liters entered and liters left, so the net change is liters while the total moved is liters.
- If the starting amount were liters, which entries of the accumulation table would change? Answer: none. measures the change since . The amount in the tank would be .
Exit check
A car's velocity is meters per second for and then decreases linearly to at . Let . Find , and , with units.
Key: meters. From to the region is a triangle with base and height , area , so meters. On that segment , so meter per second.
Extension and follow-up
- Different starting time: define . Students should find for every , so has the same slopes as . Changing the lower limit changes the accumulation function by a constant.
- From formula to theorem: on the rate is and the table gave . Ask students to confirm that the derivative of is , then predict a formula for on before checking against the table.
- After the activity, students can practice evaluating definite integrals with antiderivatives in the Definite Integral Step Tool.
The guides on the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus, accumulation functions and net change cover the written skills that follow.
Worked examples
Worked example
Finding A(6) by area
For the rate graph through , , , and , find .
- From to : a triangle with base and height , area .
- From to : a rectangle with width and height , area .
- From to : the rate falls from to , a trapezoid with area .
- Add: .
liters.
Worked example
Net change from t = 3 to t = 9 two ways
Find the net change in the amount of water in the tank from to , first by area and then with the accumulation function.
- By area, from to : a rectangle of width and height , area .
- From to : a triangle with base and height , area .
- From to : a triangle below the axis with base and height , signed area . From to : a rectangle below the axis, signed area .
- Total by area: .
- With the accumulation function: .
The net change is liters by both methods, which illustrates .
Frequently asked questions
How long does this Fundamental Theorem activity take?
About 45 minutes: 6 to set up the rate graph, 12 for the accumulation table, 7 to plot it, 9 for the slope comparison, 7 to state and use the theorem, and 4 for the exit check.
Should this come before or after teaching antiderivatives?
It is written to come before. Students use only areas and slopes, so the theorem appears as a pattern in their own tables before any antiderivative rule is used.
Why do the slope estimates miss at three points?
The estimate uses one minute on each side. At , and the rate graph has a corner, so the two sides behave differently and the average is off. A narrower estimate moves toward the true slope, which equals the rate.
Can I use real data in place of the given graph?
Yes, as long as the rate graph is made of straight segments or the class uses a trapezoidal sum for each interval. The given graph is chosen so that every area is a whole or half number.