AP Calculus BC
Parametric Derivatives: dy/dx and the Second Derivative
For a curve x = f(t), y = g(t), the slope is dy/dx = (dy/dt) / (dx/dt) wherever dx/dt is not zero. The second derivative is the t-derivative of dy/dx, divided by dx/dt again. Dividing the second derivative of y by the second derivative of x is a common error and gives a wrong answer.
The slope of a parametric curve
A parametric curve gives and separately as functions of a third variable , called the parameter. The slope of the curve is still , the rate at which changes compared with . You get it by dividing the two rates you can compute directly. This is CED Topic 9.1, Defining and Differentiating Parametric Equations.
The formula is the chain rule rearranged. If depends on and depends on , then . Divide both sides by and the slope formula appears.
The result is a function of . To find the slope at a point, substitute the value of that produces that point. If a problem gives the point as , first solve for the that lands there.
Horizontal and vertical tangents
Because the slope is a fraction, its numerator and denominator tell you where the tangent line is flat or upright.
| Condition | Tangent line |
|---|---|
| and | Horizontal |
| and | Vertical |
| and | No conclusion from the formula; the slope has the form and needs a limit |
Always check the other derivative at each candidate value of . A value where gives a horizontal tangent only if is nonzero there.
The signs of the two rates also describe the motion. When the point moves right as increases, and when it moves up.
The second derivative
The second derivative is the derivative of the slope with respect to . The slope is a function of , so you apply the same parametric rule to it: differentiate with respect to , then divide by . This is CED Topic 9.2, Second Derivatives of Parametric Equations.
The work comes in three steps.
- Find and simplify it as a function of .
- Differentiate that expression with respect to .
- Divide the result by .
A check you can run by hand
Take and for . Then and , so . Its -derivative is , and dividing by gives . Eliminating the parameter confirms it: , so and the ordinary second derivative is .
Tangent lines and concavity
A tangent line needs a point and a slope. The point comes from substituting into and . The slope comes from at the same . Then use point-slope form.
Concavity reads the same way it does for any curve. Where the curve is concave up, and where it is concave down. The sign has to be checked in terms of , since that is the variable your formula uses.
Common mistakes
- Computing for the second derivative. That quotient is a different quantity. The second derivative needs the -derivative of on top and on the bottom.
- Forgetting the final division by . Differentiating with respect to is only step two of three.
- Flipping the fraction. The rate goes on top: over .
- Calling a tangent horizontal without checking that at that value of .
- Substituting an -coordinate where a -value belongs. Every formula here is written in .
Worked examples
Worked example
Slope and tangent line at a given t
A curve is defined by and . Find at and write the equation of the tangent line there.
- Differentiate each coordinate with respect to : and .
- Form the slope: .
- Evaluate at : .
- Find the point: and , so the point is .
- Use point-slope form: , which simplifies to .
The slope is and the tangent line is .
Worked example
Horizontal and vertical tangents
Find every point where the curve , has a horizontal or vertical tangent line.
- Differentiate: and .
- Horizontal tangents need , which happens at . There , so the tangent is horizontal.
- The point at is , , so .
- Vertical tangents need , which happens at and . There equals and , both nonzero, so both tangents are vertical.
- The point at is . The point at is .
Horizontal tangent at ; vertical tangents at and .
Worked example
Second derivative and concavity on an ellipse
For , with , find in terms of , evaluate it at , and state the concavity of this part of the curve.
- Differentiate: and .
- Find the slope: .
- Differentiate the slope with respect to : .
- Divide by : .
- Evaluate at , where and : .
- For , , so on the whole interval. This is the top half of the ellipse, and it is concave down.
, which equals at . The curve is concave down for .
Frequently asked questions
Why is the second derivative not ?
The second derivative measures how the slope changes as changes. The slope is a function of , so its rate of change with respect to is its -derivative divided by . Dividing the two second -derivatives compares accelerations in and , which is a different quantity. In the ellipse example above that quotient would be , while the true second derivative is .
What happens when dx/dt and dy/dt are both zero?
The slope formula gives , so it tells you nothing by itself. The curve may have a cusp, a horizontal tangent, a vertical tangent, or something else at that value of . To decide, take the limit of as approaches the value.
Do I need to eliminate the parameter first?
No. The parametric formulas give and directly in terms of , and many parametric curves cannot be solved for as a function of at all. Eliminating the parameter is useful mainly as a check on simple curves.