AP Calculus BC
Integral Test and p-Series: Proving Convergence
If f is positive, continuous and decreasing for x >= 1 and a_n = f(n), then the series of a_n and the improper integral of f from 1 to infinity either both converge or both diverge. Applied to 1/n^p it gives the p-series rule: convergent when p > 1, divergent when p <= 1. The harmonic series, p = 1, diverges.
The test and its three conditions
The integral test trades a series for an improper integral that is often easier to evaluate. It is CED Topic 10.4, Integral Test for Convergence. Suppose for a function that meets three conditions on :
- is positive.
- is continuous.
- is decreasing.
Then the series and the integral share the same fate.
The conditions only need to hold from some point on. If is positive, continuous and decreasing for , compare with . The finitely many terms before change the sum but cannot change whether the series converges.
Running the test
- Replace with in the general term to get .
- State that is positive, continuous and decreasing on the interval, and justify the decreasing claim. Showing is the standard way.
- Write the improper integral as a limit: .
- Evaluate the integral and take the limit.
- Conclude: a finite limit means the series converges, and an infinite limit means the series diverges.
The test is a good choice when has an antiderivative you can find quickly, especially when the term pairs with or pairs with a function of , since those set up a clean substitution.
p-series and the harmonic series
A p-series has the form for a constant . Its behavior is CED Topic 10.5, Harmonic Series and p-Series.
The rule comes straight from the integral test. For , , which is finite. For the integral is , which is infinite. For the power grows without bound. For the terms do not approach , so the series diverges by the nth term test.
The case is the harmonic series, . Its terms approach and it still diverges. It is the standard reminder that terms approaching is required for convergence and is not enough to guarantee it.
Once the rule is known, use it
You do not need to rerun the integral test on a p-series. Identify , compare it with , and state the conclusion. A constant multiple does not change the verdict: diverges because does.
What the integral does not tell you
The integral test gives a verdict. It does not give the sum. The series converges because is finite, yet the sum of the series is .
For a positive, continuous, decreasing whose integral converges, the integral does bracket the sum:
For this says the sum lies between and , which agrees with .
Common mistakes
- Skipping the conditions. The test applies only when is positive, continuous and decreasing, so state and check all three.
- Reporting the value of the integral as the sum of the series.
- Writing and substituting infinity directly. Use a limit as .
- Deciding that a series converges because its terms approach . The harmonic series is the counterexample.
- Misreading the exponent. has , and has .
- Applying the p-series rule to . With in the exponent, the series is geometric.
Worked examples
Worked example
A convergent series by substitution
Determine whether converges or diverges.
- Let . For it is positive and continuous.
- Check decreasing: , which is negative for . So is decreasing on and the integral test applies.
- Integrate with , : .
- Take the limit: as , , so .
- The integral is finite, so the series converges.
The series converges by the integral test, since is finite. The sum of the series is not .
Worked example
A divergent series with a logarithm
Determine whether converges or diverges.
- Let . For it is positive and continuous.
- Check decreasing: for both and are positive and increasing, so the denominator is increasing and is decreasing.
- Integrate with , : .
- Take the limit: as , , so the improper integral diverges.
- The integral diverges, so the series diverges.
The series diverges by the integral test, even though its terms approach .
Worked example
Classifying p-series
Decide whether each series converges or diverges: (a) , (b) , (c) .
- (a) Rewrite the term as . This is a p-series with , so it diverges.
- (b) Rewrite the term as , since . This is a p-series with , so it converges.
- (c) Factor out the constant: . This is times the harmonic series, , so it diverges.
(a) diverges with ; (b) converges with ; (c) diverges as a multiple of the harmonic series.
Frequently asked questions
Does the harmonic series converge?
No. diverges. It is the p-series with , and the integral test shows it: is infinite. The partial sums grow very slowly, roughly like , which is why the divergence is easy to doubt.
Is the value of the integral the sum of the series?
No. The integral test only says whether the series converges. For the integral equals and the sum equals . The integral gives a lower bound for the sum, and adding the first term gives an upper bound.
When is the integral test the right choice?
Use it when the general term turns into a function you can integrate easily and that is positive, continuous and decreasing. Terms such as or are typical. For a plain power of , use the p-series rule directly. For terms with factorials, the ratio test fits better.