AP Calculus BC
Direct Comparison and Limit Comparison Tests Explained
Both tests settle a positive-term series by matching it to a known p-series or geometric series. Direct comparison: smaller than a convergent series converges, larger than a divergent series diverges. Limit comparison: if a_n / b_n approaches a finite positive number, both series behave the same way.
The direct comparison test
The direct comparison test works with an inequality between the terms of two series. It is the first half of CED Topic 10.6, Comparison Tests for Convergence. Suppose for all from some point on.
- If converges, then converges. A series with smaller terms than a convergent series also converges.
- If diverges, then diverges. A series with larger terms than a divergent series also diverges.
The other two combinations give no information. Being smaller than a divergent series proves nothing, and being larger than a convergent series proves nothing.
| Your series is | Comparison series | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|
| Smaller, term by term | Converges | Your series converges |
| Larger, term by term | Diverges | Your series diverges |
| Smaller, term by term | Diverges | No conclusion |
| Larger, term by term | Converges | No conclusion |
Choosing the comparison series
The comparison series should be one whose behavior you can state in a line: a p-series or a geometric series . To find it, keep only the fastest-growing part of the numerator and of the denominator, then simplify.
For , the dominant parts are and , so the terms behave like for large . Compare with , a convergent p-series. For , the dominates, so compare with the geometric series .
Decide what you expect before writing the inequality. If the comparison series converges, you need your terms to be smaller. If it diverges, you need your terms to be larger. Making a denominator smaller makes a fraction larger, and making a denominator larger makes a fraction smaller.
The limit comparison test
The limit comparison test replaces the inequality with a limit. Suppose and , and compute the limit of the ratio of the terms.
If is finite and positive, then and either both converge or both diverge. The value of does not matter beyond being finite and positive. If the limit is or infinite, this form of the test gives no conclusion, and a different comparison series is usually the fix.
For example, take . Its terms behave like . With , the ratio is , which approaches . Since is a divergent p-series with , the original series diverges.
Which of the two to use
Both tests start from the same comparison series. The choice depends on whether the inequality you need is easy to prove.
- Use direct comparison when the inequality is obvious and points the useful way, such as .
- Use limit comparison when the inequality points the wrong way or is awkward to prove. In the example above, , which is smaller than a divergent series and proves nothing directly. The limit handles it in one step.
- Use limit comparison for most rational functions of and for terms with roots of polynomials, since the limit of the ratio comes from leading terms.
Positive terms only
Both tests are stated for series with positive terms. For a series with mixed signs, apply them to to test for absolute convergence, or use the alternating series test.
Common mistakes
- Drawing a conclusion from the wrong direction: smaller than a divergent series, or larger than a convergent series.
- Stating an inequality that is false for the given terms. Test it with or and check the reasoning about the denominator.
- Naming a comparison series without saying why it converges or diverges. Give the value of or .
- Getting a limit of or infinity in the limit comparison test and treating it as finite and positive.
- Comparing with a series whose behavior is unknown. The comparison series has to be one you can classify immediately.
Worked examples
Worked example
Direct comparison with a geometric series
Determine whether converges or diverges.
- The dominates the denominator, so the terms behave like . Expect convergence, which means showing the terms are smaller than those of a convergent series.
- For every , . A larger denominator gives a smaller fraction, so .
- The series is geometric with , and , so it converges.
- By the direct comparison test, the smaller series converges.
The series converges by direct comparison with the geometric series .
Worked example
Direct comparison with a divergent p-series
Determine whether converges or diverges.
- For large the terms behave like , a divergent p-series. Expect divergence, which means showing the terms are larger than those of a divergent series.
- For , . A smaller positive denominator gives a larger fraction, so .
- The series is a p-series with , so it diverges.
- By the direct comparison test, the larger series diverges.
The series diverges by direct comparison with the p-series .
Worked example
Limit comparison when the inequality points the wrong way
Determine whether converges or diverges.
- Keep the dominant parts: . Choose . Both and are positive for .
- Direct comparison is awkward here: the numerator is larger than and the denominator is smaller than , so . Being larger than a convergent series proves nothing, so use the limit comparison test.
- Form the ratio: .
- Take the limit by dividing the numerator and denominator by : .
- The limit is finite and positive, and is a convergent p-series with . So both series converge.
The series converges by the limit comparison test with , since the limit of the ratio is .
Frequently asked questions
When should I use limit comparison over direct comparison?
Use limit comparison when you know which simple series your terms resemble and the inequality needed for direct comparison is false or hard to prove. Rational functions of , such as , are the typical case: the limit of the ratio comes straight from the leading terms.
What series should I compare with?
Almost always a p-series or a geometric series. Keep the dominant term of the numerator and the dominant term of the denominator, simplify, and drop any constant factor. The result is the comparison series.
What does the limit comparison test say if the limit is 0 or infinity?
The version stated here requires a finite positive limit, so a limit of or infinity gives no conclusion from it. That outcome usually means the comparison series does not match the growth of your terms. Choose a comparison series that matches more closely and try again.