AP Calculus AB and BC
Derivative as a Limit: Both Forms and How to Spot Them
The derivative of f at x = a is the limit of the difference quotient: the limit as h approaches 0 of (f(a + h) - f(a)) / h, or equivalently the limit as x approaches a of (f(x) - f(a)) / (x - a). When a limit matches either form, identify f and a, then find f'(a) with derivative rules.
From secant slope to tangent slope
The slope of the line through two points on a graph, and , is the difference quotient . That is an average rate of change over an interval of width , the starting point of Topic 2.1, Defining Average and Instantaneous Rates of Change at a Point.
The derivative is the limit of those secant slopes as . When the limit exists, it is the slope of the tangent line at and the instantaneous rate of change of there. You can watch the secant line turn into the tangent line in the secant to tangent interactive.
The two limit forms
There are two equivalent ways to write the derivative at a point (Topic 2.2, Defining the Derivative of a Function and Using Derivative Notation). The first lets the gap between the inputs shrink to :
The second names the moving input and lets it approach :
Substituting turns one into the other, since then and exactly when . Leaving the point general in the first form gives the derivative as a function:
Computing a derivative from the definition
Substituting right away always gives , so the work is algebra that removes the from the denominator.
- Write by replacing every in the formula with .
- Form the difference and simplify. Every term without an should cancel.
- Factor out of what is left and cancel it with the in the denominator.
- Now let by substitution.
The simplifying step depends on the function. Polynomials need expanding, fractions need a common denominator, and square roots need multiplication by the conjugate. Keep writing on every line until the step where you substitute.
Recognizing a derivative written as a limit
Some limits are derivatives in disguise. If a limit has the shape of either form, you can skip the algebra: identify the function and the point , differentiate with rules, and evaluate .
| Limit | Value | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Check the constant
After choosing and , confirm that the constant in the numerator really is . In the second row, , so subtracting shows up as . If the constant does not match, the limit is not that derivative.
Where students lose points
- Writing as . For , .
- Substituting before canceling. The in the denominator has to be gone first.
- Dropping the limit notation partway through, or keeping it after substituting.
- Losing a sign when subtracting . Put in parentheses before distributing the minus sign.
- Picking the wrong in a disguised limit. In the form, is the number added to ; in the other form, is the number approaches.
The limit in the definition does not always exist. For at , the difference quotient is , which equals for and for . The one-sided limits disagree, so does not exist, which matches the corner in the graph.
Worked examples
Worked example
A polynomial from the definition
Use the limit definition to find for .
- Write : .
- Subtract : .
- Divide by : for .
- Take the limit: .
Worked example
A square root, using the conjugate
Use the limit definition to find for , where .
- Set up the difference quotient: .
- Multiply the numerator and denominator by the conjugate . The numerator becomes , so the quotient is .
- Cancel : the quotient equals for .
- Take the limit by substituting : .
Worked example
A limit that is a derivative in disguise
Evaluate .
- Compare with . The expression plays the role of , which suggests and .
- Check the constant: , which matches the being subtracted. The limit is .
- Differentiate with the known rule: .
- Evaluate at : .
Frequently asked questions
Are the two limit forms of the derivative really the same?
Yes. Substituting into gives . They always produce the same value, so use whichever makes the algebra easier.
What is the difference between and ?
is a number: the slope of the tangent line at the single point . is a function that gives that slope at every where the limit exists. You can find by computing first and then substituting .
Do I have to use the limit definition every time I differentiate?
No. Once you know the derivative rules, use them. Use the definition when a problem tells you to, when you need to recognize a limit as a derivative, or when you are checking differentiability at a point where a function's formula changes.